Sex and The City: Bad For Women?

POINT: It started with the opening line - Carrie tells us that women come to New York for "labels and love." Consider the first one. For 144 minutes, we watch as the four slick, game-playing career gals fetishize stuff: car trunks full of Chanel, Vuitton handbags, five-figure wedding gowns, and a walk-in closet for all those Manolos - paid for by Prince Charming. Yes, TV Carrie loved fashion, but in the show, she picked up the tab herself (if on credit), and it was all just backdrop; the larger point was that women could put career first, pay their own way, and get laid as they pleased. As for love, the movie serves up the corny teenage variety, so commodified it appears on a key chain. And sex is barely in sight! If the show proved that the 30-something woman could be "single and fabulous," the movie is a warning that if she makes it to 40 without her handsome prince, she's pretty much screwed. -Yael Kohen

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

COUNTERPOINT: I saw SATC: The Movie three times, each with the same slap-happy grin that hijacks my face when a guy unexpectedly hits on me. Despite the vehement drum-banging of my colleagues, who rail about the "film's" gender stereotypes - Carrie's near-gravitational pull to the altar, career and family make Miranda a dull girl, yada yada yada - the glossy chick flick isn't meant to be women's studies fodder! It delivers what it promises: the abject consumerism, frank sexual dialogue, and hunt for a satisfying relationship that marked the HBO series. The result? A $400 million box-office ballbuster that flipped the bird to the old Hollywood credo that women can't open films. Men are inundated with brainless popcorn-chompers like Transformers; now that we've shown our seismic social capital, studios will start courting us with our own steady diet of blissfully mindless blockbuster fare. That's two steps forward in my book. -Lea Goldman

More from Marie Claire:
Politics
Share
First Woman Enters Training to Become a Navy SEAL
Politics
Share
Sean Spicer's Legacy, as Told by Melissa McCarthy's Best Impressions
Sean Spicer
Politics
Share
The Best Twitter Reactions to Sean Spicer's Resignation from the White House
Politics
Share
Did the Japanese Prime Minister's Wife Pretend Not to Speak English to Avoid Talking to Trump?
GOP senators vote against Obamacare repeal
Politics
Share
Three GOP Women Just Tanked the Latest Effort to Repeal Obamacare
Politics
Share
Get Ready to Feel Every Single Feeling: Justin Trudeau Met a Child of Syrian Refugees Who Was Named After Him
Politics
Share
Ivanka Trump's Clothing Company Has Been Accused of Hiring Low Wage Workers Abroad
Politics
Share
Betsy DeVos's Approach to Sexual Assault on Campus Is Terrifying
Politics
Share
Defunding Planned Parenthood Will Be Disastrous for the HIV Epidemic—Why Aren't We Talking About That?
Politics
Share
Trump's Goodbye Handshake with President Macron Was Basically a Deranged Tug-Of-War