6 Reasons Why Men Prefer Women with a "Dark Side"

Most Popular

Old sports:

Those of you who have been reading this blog for a while probably know that while I can be quite giddy and impulsive at times--even downright silly--I also have a bit of a "dark streak." I'm not saying I'm anywhere near evil--I don't mean "dark" like that. But I can occasionally get a little too fixated on gloomy ideas. (Like: Life has no meaning. And I have no power over anything. And Some day, my favorite cactus plant will die.) As far as I can tell, that dark streak has never done me one bit of good--it seems to have hurt me more than helped when it comes to dating and relationships. All the same, in the last few months, a strange preponderance of my male friends have claimed that they're only attracted to chicks who have "a dark side"--that if a chick doesn't have one, they're not interested.

Advertisement - Continue Reading Below

Why, exactly? And what do they mean by that?

I tracked down a few of the men in question, and demanded that they pony up with some explanations. Here's what they had to say:

One friend of mine, 38-year-old Bear Cummings*--a hipster hiding out in a corporate job--says the appeal of women who wear midnight-colored glasses is that they seem harder to get than your average female. He presents a very interesting reason why that might be so: "Women with a dark side bring out some protective paternalistic instinct--which leads me to pursuing them in a way that borders on the obsessive--which inevitably causes them to reject me. That, in turn, leads to mania on my part."
Here's 25-year-old Charlie Dupont on the topic: "Part of the appeal with chicks who seem to think deeply about things is you have to work harder to penetrate the surface--no pun intended. It adds to the feeling that you're on the chase."

A 29-year-old copywriter I know had this wisdom to impart: "Girls with a dark side are more exciting. They're the opposite of the docile, passive, 'good girl' who may be a great mother someday but is a boring girlfriend or fling. Plus, their interest in us suggests we, too, have some intriguing contours."
The copywriter had another detail to add: "They give us the feeling that we're being objectified somehow, or 'used'--which is a rarity for men, and can be an ego trip."

31-year-old Rico Miniver has this to say: "I want to point out that when I say 'dark,' I don't necessarily mean a woman who wears a lot of black leather and has tattoos. But I do prefer women who are capable of skepticism, even cynicism, because that signals they don't accept the obvious, superficial "truths" we are taught to believe. They question conventional wisdom. They aren't so much negative as authentic in the way they choose to approach cultural and political ideals.

Bear had some more insight: "If we can win the bad girl over, then we get to enact our fantasies of being the one to rescue her from the cruel world. This kind of fantasy is more commonly associated with women--it's fairly common that you hear about a female who is trying to save a screwed-up man--but certain men are into that kind of thing too."
And Bear continues: "I assume that girls who have experienced existential angst are going to be sluttier, and more into some of the same unhealthy lifestyle choices I make at times: drinking too much, doing drugs, that kind of thing."

Lovelies: What do you think? Ladies--do you have dark sides? Do you think they help or hurt you, dating-wise? Do you find the reasons outlined above outrageous? Or understandable?

And men: Are you into women with dark sides? Or ... not so much? Why or why not?



*All pseudonyms are porn-star names.

Love & Sex
3 Divorce Attorneys on How Power Couples Handle Cheating
​​In light of Lemonade. ​
Woman in bed, black and white.
Love & Sex
My Weird, Fun, Life-Changing Quest to Have Sex with 100 Different People
For my milestone birthday, I set some *goals.*​
Love & Sex
Adventures of a Sex Phone Operator: The Surprising Highs, the Grossest Lows, and the Lesson I Took Away from It All
​I knew the experience might change me—but I didn't realize how much.​
Love & Sex
5 Affirmations for the Modern Dating-App-Using Girl
Repeat until you don't feel like a broken-down, garbage person anymore. ​
Love & Sex
I Tried "Sex Dust" and Here's What Happened
A scientific experiment of the libido kind.​
Love & Sex
​10 Ways Weed Makes Me a Better Girlfriend
On always taking the high road.​
black and white bride
Love & Sex
The Emotional Weight of Being a Wife
​​Why is the maintenance of our relationship my responsibility?​
Multi-colored condoms
Love & Sex
Why It Sucks to Date as a Happily Childfree Woman
​​My male partners assumed that deep down, I *really* wanted kids. ​
Love & Sex
I Made My Stomach Pooch Its Own Tinder Account
And still got all the swipes. ​
Love & Sex
How My Boyfriend and I Finally Learned to Fight
A guide from comedian Nikki Glaser.​