"Sweater Unicorns" Exist—I Tracked Down 5 of Them
The perfect mix of soft, trendy, and crafted to last.
It’s that time of year again! Time to start pulling out all the good stuff from the back of your closet, a.k.a. the cozies and all the layers. Luckily, NYC has been very cooperative and seasonally chilly, just as I ordered. This means I've had plenty of opportunities to slide back into my knitwear rotation.
But here’s the thing: thousands of new sweaters hit the market every year. Many are cute, some not so much. Very few actually strike the perfect balance between softness, trendiness, and long-term appeal.
Fortunately, I’ve sifted through the itchy ones, the pilling disasters, and everything in between. After a long and arduous search in pursuit of perfection, here are the five "sweater unicorns" that you'll actually want to reach for year over year—you’re welcome!
Reformation Easton Cashmere Sweater
I audibly gasped when I took this one out of the packaging. The fit is absolutely stunning, and it’s just so cool. The oversized sleeves, the interesting neckline (just the right level of deep), and the cinched waist—it all comes together perfectly. You can dress it up or down, and it looks great with a cute black low-rise trouser for a night out. I’m making it my personal mission to find all the ways I can wear it.
Fit: Oversized with a cinched waist.
Material: 95% cashmere, 5% wool
Anine Bing Lee Sweater
A red sweater belongs in every wardrobe. It makes sense for every season, which is why I feel like I can justify the price point on this one. The slouchy, relaxed fit is something so many sweaters miss, but my main obsession is the COLOR! This red is the perfect holiday shade: not too orangey, not too blue, just right. When you find perfection, you gotta act, people!
Fit: Relaxed
Material: 100% cashmere
Jenni Kayne Cropped Cashmere Jet V-Neck
Currently wearing this as I type. Every time I’ve caught a chill these past few weeks, I’ve found myself gravitating right back to it. It’s such a staple, with just the right amount of trendy flair thanks to the V-neck. It’s thick, cozy, and impossibly soft. I couldn’t recommend it more.
Fit: Slightly cropped, boxy
Material: 100% cashmere
COS Pure Cashmere Mock-Neck Sweater
This sweater! The fashion gods somehow read my mind, because I had been praying for a sweater in this trending color. After seeing what I conservatively estimate to be no fewer than 50 targeted ads, I finally caved, and thank goodness I did. This electric purple is even better and more vibrant IRL, and it makes such a statement. I was worried it would wash me out as a blonde, but I’m happy to report it looks good on blondes and brunettes alike. If the color feels like too much of a departure from your regular style, there’s also a lovely black and gray option in the same silhouette. It's soft, relaxed, and it drapes just right.
Fit: Regular fit
Material: 100% cashmere
Guest in Residence Oversized Crew
Miss Gigi just nails it every time. Guest in Residence does sweaters so well (it’s almost like that’s their whole M.O.)! Jokes aside, this sweater is just great. It’s slouchy, big, and feels like something you stole from your boyfriend’s closet. Very model off-duty. It is quite oversized, so I’d suggest sizing down. Don’t worry, it’ll still be oversized, you just won’t be swimming in it.
Fit: Oversized
Material: 100% Cashmere
The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.
Bailey Burke is a New York–based contributing fashion editor to Marie Claire and Who What Wear. By day, she works on the Creator & Community team, overseeing influencer and branded content programs across both publications. It's a role that keeps her deeply plugged into the fashion and creator landscape—and has given her a keen eye for the dernier cri. Once (accurately) labeled a shopaholic, she now considers it market research.
A Chicago native who spent three years in Los Angeles before landing in New York City, Bailey's unique style is a direct product of everywhere she has lived. Outside of work, you'll find her planning her next trip, trying new restaurants, attending concerts, or convincing herself she needs just oneeee more thing in her cart. Follow her on Instagram at @baileyyburke.