Why We Need To Hear the Sobs of Children At the Border, According to Psychologists
"We need to bear witness to both the best parts of humanity and to the worst parts of humanity."


One of the children shouts: “Papá, Papá, ay, no, Papá.” As consular workers speak, and other children ask for mothers and family members, the cry persists in the background, “Papá, Papá, Papá,” punctuated with sobs.
The audio obtained by ProPublica of 10 inconsolable Central American children desperately crying out for the parents they have been forcibly separated from at the U.S. border has been played all around the country, and by now, the world.
But some haven’t been able to bring themselves to listen to the grueling seven minutes.
I’ve talked to people who are calling their congressional representatives, canvassing the streets, reporting diligently on the atrocities on the border. But still, they can’t bring themselves to hit play.
Is it selfish to avoid this audio? Do we need to hear exactly what is happening (opens in new tab) in order to understand the ramifications of this brutal policy?
Psychologist Dana L. Sinopoli, Psy.D said that while she can identify with how hard it is to process the recording, it is crucial we stay engaged by paying attention to the stories coming from the border — even those that are the most difficult to see and listen to.
“It’s a bit like not going to a Holocaust museum or the new slavery museum in Alabama,” she tells me. “We need to bear witness to both the best parts of humanity and to the worst parts of humanity, and that is not always an easy thing to do, but we have to recognize the full continuum of what humans are capable of doing to one another.”
The former president of the American Psychoanalytic Association, Mark D. Smaller, says he listened to the audio several times last night. Though he’s a professional, the experience was “almost unbearable,” he says.
Smaller, who has spoken out against the Trump administration’s policy, explains that the listener “immediately senses and experiences the kind of helplessness that these children are experiencing.”
He describes helplessness as “the worst of all possible human feelings”—worse than anger, loss or sadness.
It’s a bit like not going to a Holocaust museum or the new slavery museum in Alabama.
Depending on your own personal experiences, Smaller says you can “feel slightly traumatized by it,” especially if you’ve experienced a similar trauma or separation anxiety. But still, he thinks it is important for people to engage with the news in order to “understand the depth of how inhumane” this policy is to children.
Sinopoli said she feels like we are “barraged more than ever before,” with so much news that “it’s not only hard to keep up with, it’s hard to want to keep up with.” A recent Pew poll found that most Americans agree, seven out of 10 people “feel worn out by the amount of news” there is.
As a result, people can start dissociating from the tragedies in the headlines, even while looking at an image as heartbreaking (opens in new tab) as the one of the 2-year-old girl sobbing as the border agents detain her mother.
A 2-year-old girl and her mother are stopped by US Border Patrol.
“There is a self-protective, self-preservative quality about reading the news and having the emotional center of our brain not fully engaged,” says Sinopoli, “But it means we are not actually empathizing or experiencing this on an emotional level.”
Both Smaller and Sinopoli stress the importance of self-care, particularly for individuals who are recovering from similar trauma. This can include taking breaks, going for a walk or doing yoga. But it can also include taking action (opens in new tab).
“Write letters to the editor, write your congressman, organize a protest,” says Smaller.
Sinopoli adds: “It’s so easy to feel crazy. I think this is when we need to stay connected to other people who feel as strongly as we do.”
As Slate’s Dahlia Lithwick wrote (opens in new tab)
This is the scene in the movie where even though you want to fall asleep in the snowdrift, you need to get up and walk around. If you decide to stop swimming and just drift for a while, you’re apt to wake up in a land you don’t recognize. Because “going numb” is the gateway drug to acceptance.
And, most importantly, the kids in the tapes don’t have the option of tuning it out. There have been recent studies (opens in new tab) about the harmful, life-long effect the stress of family separation can have on the brain.
”The younger the child, the worse it is,” says Smaller of the longterm effects. “The world has suddenly become very unpredictable” to the child and even if they are reunited with their parents they could worry they will be separated from them again at any moment.
Sinopoli says: “Regardless of reunification, regardless if the policy were to stop tomorrow, none of this undoes the trauma of being forcibly ripped from their parents.”
Lorena O'Neil is a reporter and photojournalist based in New Orleans covering social justice, culture, religion, and the environment. She has written for The Atlantic, Elle, Esquire, CNN, NPR and The Hollywood Reporter.
-
'Bachelor in Paradise' 2022: Everything We Know
There's a lot going on when it comes to 'Bachelor in Paradise' this year—but we probably won't get Lil Jon back.
By Jenny Hollander
-
'Manifest' Season 4: Everything We Know
It's official: The once-canceled NBC show is returning for a final chapter (or two) on Netflix.
By Jenny Hollander
-
Halsey’s Latest Eye Makeup Look Is a Lesson in Color Blocking
They only used three About Face products to get the look.
By Samantha Holender
-
The Supreme Court's Mississippi Abortion Rights Case: What to Know
The case could threaten Roe v. Wade.
By Megan DiTrolio
-
Sex Trafficking Victims Are Being Punished. A New Law Could Change That.
Victims of sexual abuse are quietly criminalized. Sara's Law protects kids that fight back.
By Dr. Devin J. Buckley and Erin Regan
-
My Family and I Live in Navajo Nation. We Don't Have Access to Clean Running Water
"They say that the United States is one of the wealthiest countries in the world. Why are citizens still living with no access to clean water?"
By Amanda L. As Told To Rachel Epstein
-
30 Ways Women Still Aren't Equal to Men
If anyone tries to tell you otherwise, show them these statistics.
By Megan Friedman
-
Cory Booker and Rosario Dawson's Relationship Is No More
After three years of dating, the power couple have decided they're better off as friends.
By Marie Claire Editors
-
Education for Women and Girls Is Crucial for Climate Justice
In an excerpt from her new book, 'A Bigger Picture,' Ugandan climate activist Vanessa Nakate discusses the impact educated African women and girls can have on solving the climate crisis.
By Vanessa Nakate
-
It’s Time to End Equal Pay Days and Pass the Equal Rights Amendment
The passage of the ERA is a chance for our country to prove it truly values women.
By Hala Ayala
-
In Conversation: Secretary Jennifer Granholm and Emily Tisch Sussman
“It’s ridiculous that we’re the only advanced nation on the planet that doesn’t help families with childcare.”
By Emily Tisch Sussman