MC Book Club: A Country Called Home by Kim Barnes
This month, the MC Book Club follows one couple's ill-advised attempt to go country in Kim Barnes' A Country Called Home. Worth your precious discretionary dollar? Read on...Last month's Book Club: Air, by G. Willow Wilson.

Celebrity news, beauty, fashion advice, and fascinating features, delivered straight to your inbox!
Thank you for signing up to . You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.
THE PLOT: It's 1960 and Thomas and Helen Deracotte have just escaped their highfalutin Connecticut roots for the simple life on an Idaho farm. But despite their fantasy of eating wild trout and canning their own preserves, the newlywed dilettantes know nothing about tending crops or rebuilding their dilapidated farmhouse. What's worse, Thomas goes from being a promising young doctor to a hapless fisherman, leaving Helen all alone each morning to care for their newborn daughter—and to look elsewhere for comfort.
ANDREA (PHOTO EDITOR): I didn't like this book. What's the takeaway? A young wife from a wealthy family doesn't want to be near her overbearing mom. So she and her husband move to the sticks, and then—surprise, surprise!—she feels isolated. It was just so predictable.
EILEEN (ASSISTANT EDITOR): I've never understood stories where kids from rich families try so hard to reject them. It's like, what's wrong with a cushy life?
JIHAN (EDITORIAL ASSISTANT): It's the hippie ideal of living without. Helen and Thomas have this fantasy of going back to nature, but the reality isn't so idyllic.
LEA (FEATURES EDITOR): I liked the book. And I think Helen's disillusionment with motherhood would be relatable for a lot of women. She thinks it's going to be fulfilling, and instead she feels stifled and alone. Her husband has checked out, and she's got no sisters or friends to help her. I could see how she would end up having an affair with the handyman.
EILEEN: I loved that scene after Helen first has her daughter, Elise, and she gets so claustrophobic: "Helen sometimes felt shackled. Any desire she might have to read, explore, even look out over the river was stymied by the weight of her breasts emptied but already swelling with new milk, Elise's cries for more."
ANDREA: I had no sympathy for her. The fact that she was baffled by the lack of plumbing in a house she bought sight unseen was ridiculous. And the writing! Every sentence had three adjectives.
LEA: It did feel a bit like an Iowa Writers' Workshop exercise, with ridiculously florid descriptions. Like, why call it a rock when you can call it "pebbled agate"? Too many mulberries, ospreys, and laurel.
JIHAN: I disagree. I liked the writing. And since Barnes actually lived this kind of life, it seemed genuine to me.
ANDREA: The other issue I had was that the book drew all these way-too-obvious parallels. For example, Helen and Elise both date boys their parents don't approve of, and both want desperately to escape their roots. Come on ...
JIHAN: But there was the larger theme, about how the desire to break away from your family exists everywhere, from tony Connecticut to middle-of-nowhere Idaho.
EILEEN: Right. And there was this sense that no matter where you go, you can't escape yourself. Helen and Thomas went to Idaho to see what they were made of. And they found there wasn't much there.
SHOULD YOU READ IT?
EILEEN: NO
ANDREA: NO
JIHAN: YES
LEA: YES
-
Prince Andrew Still Receiving Taxpayer-Funded Police Protection
Protecting the Duke of York doesn't come cheap.
By Alicia Lutes
-
Don't Insult Queen Elizabeth's Corgis
A family member said they "should be shot" and QEII had something to say about it.
By Alicia Lutes
-
How to Treat Hormonal Acne: A Dermatologist’s Guide
Peace out, PMS pimples.
By Samantha Holender
-
29 Nude Movies With Porn-Level Nudity
All the nakedness of porn, but with the plot and storylines of mainstream film.
By Kayleigh Roberts
-
46 Sad Movies for When You Need a Good Cry
Better than crying about the state of the world, right?
By Cady Drell
-
The 15 Best Shows Featuring the 'Squid Game' Cast
If you can't get enough of Squid Game, try these K-dramas next.
By Quinci LeGardye
-
The 95 Best Movies of All Time
These must-watch films are essentials.
By Bianca Rodriguez
-
The 14 Korean Thrillers on Netflix You Need to See
Good luck sleeping after watching these.
By Quinci LeGardye
-
Join #ReadWithMC: Marie Claire's Virtual Monthly Book Club
Never feel guilty about skipping book club again.
By The Editors
-
The 50 Best Love Songs of All Time
The best, most romantic love songs ever written, spanning every genre.
By Gabrielle Ulubay
-
The 80 Best Romantic Comedies of All Time
Where does your fave fall on the list?
By The Editors