Republican Commentator S.E. Cupp Has a Strong Message for the GOP: Reform or Become Relics

In a viral video clip filmed in the wake of this summer's historic gay-marriage ruling, Republican political commentator S.E. Cupp stands her ground: "I've always thought supporting gay marriage was, in fact, a deeply conservative thing to do."

Eyewear, Glasses, Vision care, Jewellery, Fashion accessory, Necklace, Body jewelry, Day dress, Podium,
(Image credit: Courtesy CNN)

On June 26, as the nation was reacting to the Supreme Court ruling that effectively legalized same-sex marriages, conservative political commentator S.E. Cupp, 36, was at CNN's Washington, D.C., headquarters preparing to go on-air. When the camera cut to her, she was noticeably overcome with emotion from watching gay-marriage supporters celebrate the decision in front of the court. "These people are not pariahs," she said, with tears in her eyes. "They're patriots." She continued, daring members of her party, who she said would become relics if they don't shift their thinking on the issue, to "look at their faces…and ask yourselves if they deserve the same dignity that the rest of us get to enjoy." Here, Cupp discusses her viral moment.

Marie Claire: Why did you react that way?

S. E. Cupp: I was just a human being in that moment. I like to think I'm a pretty professional person, but it's hard to look at the faces of those families and not see the joy in their eyes and feel happy for them that they get to enjoy the life that many of us tend to take for granted.

MC: Have your differences with the party ever made you question your loyalty?

SEC: No, I am very secure in my beliefs. I'm pro-life, progun, for limited government and lower taxes. But I've always thought supporting gay marriage was, in fact, a deeply conservative thing to do. If we support marriage as economically stabling and socially empowering, why wouldn't we want more people to enter it?

MC: Does it concern you that many of the GOP candidates for president in 2016 issued statements opposing the ruling?

SEC: I'm not surprised—I don't expect hearts and minds to change overnight...Many Republicans have come out in the past couple of years in support of gay rights. Maybe it will take awhile to get to the presidential level—like it did in the Democratic Party—but I'm very encouraged.

MC: Has the party's position on marriage hurt its standing with young people?

SEC: Absolutely. I hear all the time from young people who say, "I would be conservative if it wasn't for gay marriage." They say, "I know too many gay people to be part of a party that thinks there's something wrong with them." I don't want my party to become obsolete, especially when we have so much to offer to young people.

MC: Do you worry about opposing your party in such vocal ways?

SEC: I enjoy challenging my party to think differently about things. There's always a little backlash, but I recover just fine. They haven't asked for my conservative card back yet!

This article appears in the September issue of Marie Claire, on newsstands now.

Kayla Webley Adler

Kayla Webley Adler is the Deputy Editor of ELLE magazine. She edits cover stories, profiles, and narrative features on politics, culture, crime, and social trends. Previously, she worked as the Features Director at Marie Claire magazine and as a Staff Writer at TIME magazine.