Paid parental leave for Starbucks employees boils down to one question: Do you wear an apron?
That's how Jess Svabenik, a Starbucks barista in Silverdale, Washington, interprets the company's new paid parental leave policy (opens in new tab), which provides 12 weeks of paid leave to parents—moms, dads, adoptive parents, and domestic partners—with six additional paid weeks for birth mothers. The catch? This option is only available to corporate employees, "the people who wear regular clothes," said Svabenik, an eight-year Starbucks employee. Those who wear aprons and work behind counters receive far less: six weeks of paid leave for birth mothers, and no paid leave for dads or adoptive parents.
For Svabenik, pregnant with her fourth child and due in late July, the new policy is surprising—and undermines the goodwill Starbucks had been building with its employees through innovative workplace benefits (opens in new tab) that, until now, haven't discriminated between store workers and corporate employees. "They didn't seem to understand why we would want the same the kind of benefits as corporate staff," Svabenik says of the response she got when she flagged the issue internally.
Svabenik and another barista, Kristen Picciolo, from Medina, Ohio, recently sat down with VP of benefits Ron Crawford and VP of global policy and advocacy Zulima Espinel for a private meeting to discuss their concerns. Picciolo brought her four-month-old son, Adam, along.
"They were kind of confused that we were there," Svabenik says. "That's the hardest part to process: That there are people who reap these kinds of benefits and aren't interested in passing them on to those in a lesser position."
The following day, Picciolo, who's worked at the company for a year, spoke up at the Starbucks shareholders meeting in Seattle, addressing Howard Schultz and Kevin Johnson, Starbucks' outgoing and incoming CEOs, respectively. (Johnson officially became CEO last week). Picciolo was nervous; she'd never traveled cross-country before and yet here she was, standing in a crowded auditorium in front of the two most senior executives at her company. "As a parent I know how important it is to spend those first few months with your new baby," she told them (opens in new tab). "I just want you to maybe reconsider, and extend this crucial benefit to all employees." Johnson thanked her for her comments and said he remained open to hearing feedback from employees.
Starbucks' employee benefits are "something we take a great deal of pride in," says Reggie Borges, a spokesperson for the company. Borges says their paid parental leave policy is "far above and beyond the standard for retail" employers. That's true: Only twelve percent (opens in new tab) of U.S. private-sector workers have access to paid parental leave. Still, the separation in benefits between white- and blue-collar workers has a real impact. Compared to their salaried counterparts, hourly workers are less likely to have paid leave (opens in new tab) benefits. Without such, the economic strain of staying home with a child can be so great that nearly one in four employed American mothers (opens in new tab) return to work less than two weeks after giving birth.
Starbucks isn't the only large employer to offer different paid leave benefits for corporate versus retail employees. Analysis by the non-profit PL+US (opens in new tab) (Paid Leave for the U.S.) found that several large American employers like Wal-mart and Yum Brands offer 12 and 16 weeks paid maternity leave for corporate workers, but zero weeks of paid leave for hourly workers. By contrast, Target, Hilton, and Nordstrom provide the same family leave benefits for staffers, regardless of level (though all provide fewer weeks off for new dads than moms).
PL+US's program director, Annie Sartor, believes Starbucks's policy discrepancy is "not a matter of cost" for the company but simply because they haven't heard enough feedback from baristas and in-store workers, something PL+US is hoping to change with online petitions (opens in new tab) before the policy takes effect in October.
For her part, Picciolo has faith that Starbucks will eventually enact an equal policy. "I love working here," she says. "But they can do much better than this."
Rebecca Gale is an award-winning journalist covering the nexus of politics and people in Washington, D.C. She is currently a writer with the Better Life Lab at New America. Her work has appeared in The Washington Post, Roll Call, Marie Claire, Cosmopolitan, and Health Affairs, among other outlets. Follow her on Twitter @beckgale
'Harry & Meghan' Shows Previously Unseen Photos of Archie and Lilibet
They're *so* cute.
By Brooke Knappenberger
Prince Harry Met Meghan Markle Through His Secret Instagram Account
Their relationship may or may not have something to do with the "dog ears" filter.
By Brooke Knappenberger
The Ultimate Guide to Paris
Where to stay and what to do in the City of Lights.
By Sara Holzman
Peloton’s Selena Samuela on Turning Tragedy Into Strength
Before becoming a powerhouse cycling instructor, Selena Samuela was an immigrant trying to adjust to new environments and new versions of herself.
By Emily Tisch Sussman
This Mutual Fund Firm Is Helping to Create a More Sustainable Future
Amy Domini and her firm, Domini Impact Investments LLC, are inspiring a greater and greener world—one investor at a time.
Power Players Build on Success
"The New Normal" left some brands stronger than ever. We asked then what lies ahead.
By Maria Ricapito
Don't Stress! You Can Get in Good Shape Money-wise
Yes, maybe you eat paleo and have mastered crow pose, but do you practice financial wellness?
By Sallie Krawcheck
The Book Club Revolution
Lots of women are voracious readers. Other women are capitalizing on that.
By Lily Herman
The Future of Women and Work
The pandemic has completely upended how we do our jobs. This is Marie Claire's guide to navigating your career in a COVID-19 world.
By Megan DiTrolio
Black-Owned Coworking Spaces Are Providing a Safe Haven for POC
For people of color, many of whom prefer to WFH, inclusive coworking spaces don't just offer a place to work—they cultivate community.
By Megan DiTrolio
Where Did All My Work Friends Go?
The pandemic has forced our work friendships to evolve. Will they ever be the same?
By Rachel Epstein