Instead of abstract ideals like life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness, German Basic Law guarantees the freedom to choose one's occupation. And since 2002, when the German Prostitution Act was introduced, sex work has been classified as one of those occupations. On paper, at least.
The logistics: While the practices of buying and selling sex are legal, things like pimping, advertising, and engaging the services of a trafficking victim are not. And contrary to the belief that legalizing prostitution will invite more human trafficking abuses, the situation in Germany has shown that it actually does the opposite. The number of victims trafficked has dropped, and clients themselves are often the ones to report suspected trafficking to the police. To date, the German sex industry has an estimated worth of 15 billion Euros.
The biggest problem when it comes to prostitution in Germany, in fact, is that it isn't legal enough.
"Sex workers are highly stigmatized and sex work is still mainly regulated by criminal law," explains Undine de Rivière, a spokeswoman for the German Trade Association for Erotic and Sexual Services, a group founded by sex workers to defend their rights against attacks from conservative politicians.
"We have 'restricted areas' where sex work is illegal, which is most small towns and major areas in larger cities," she says. "About 97% of the city of Munich is a restricted area for all kinds of sex work including meeting clients in their homes or hotel rooms."
Despite the stigma, sex workers in Germany function as independent contractors—they earn their money legally, which means they also pay taxes and have access to the same benefits as workers in other industries. Income taxes in Germany are high when compared to the U.S., but the benefits that come accompany them, like unemployment support and subsidized health care costs, are numerous.
There is no reliable data about exactly how many active sex workers there are in the country, since many are short-term and prefer not to reveal their occupation, but it's estimated that there are more per capita than anywhere else on the European continent. And of that nebulous figure, studies estimate that 94% of them are women.
"To say you are a sex worker is only possible for a few of us," says Kristina Marlen, a tantric dominatrix and sex workers' rights activist who cites her work as a personal calling she enjoys and is open about. "But this is not true for all sex workers. Some do it just to earn a living."
The data is hard to track, but in 2008 it was estimated that 60% of sex workers in Germany were migrants from less economically stable countries. These women are often young (the legal age for prostitution is 18), don't speak the language, and therefore aren't aware of their access to institutional support. Under the Protection Against Infection Act (IfSG), for example, they can seek anonymous health counselling services. (Though the voluntary and anonymous aspects would disappear if conservative politicians got their way.)
It's larger considerations like this that de Rivière knows are major factors in the stigmas and victimization of sex workers. "The way to make sure a large and diverse group of self-employed people gets treated fairly," she says, "is to give them rights and options and make sure they know about them."
You should also check out:
Stay In The Know
Marie Claire email subscribers get intel on fashion and beauty trends, hot-off-the-press celebrity news, and more. Sign up here.
For Deepica Mutyala, Entrepreneurship Is Worth the Sacrifice
The Live Tinted founder talks having it all—but not all at once.
By Gabrielle Ulubay
"It's Been Hell on Earth": Inside Alabama's Fertility Crisis
Last week, the state's Supreme Court ruled that frozen embryos are legally considered children. 'Marie Claire' spoke with affected women about how they’re grappling with an uncertain future.
By Jessica Goodman
Sydney Sweeney's Canadian Tuxedo Is Unlike Anyone Else's
She made the double denim look completely her own.
By Aaron Royce
35 Nude Movies With Porn-Level Nudity
Lots of steamy nudity ahead.
By Kayleigh Roberts
What's 'Bridgerton' Without the Sex?
Season 2 of the Netflix show betrays its romance roots by barely acknowledging or indulging women’s sexual desires that the genre is celebrated for.
By Kathleen Walsh
The 35 Best Sex Podcasts of All Time
Some are funny, some are informative, all are NSFW.
By Bianca Rodriguez
The Best LGBTQ+ Movies of All Time
Absolutely required viewing.
By Katherine J. Igoe
Nancy Jo Sales Wants Women to Know It’s Not You, It’s Dating Apps
The writer went viral for trashing Tinder in Vanity Fair. Her new book, Nothing Personal, pulls the curtain on online dating back even further.
By Maria Ricapito
The Best 'Normal People' Sex Scenes, Ranked
Warning: Extreme steaminess ahead.
By Kayleigh Roberts
The Best Twitter Reactions to Netflix's 'Too Hot to Handle'
Unsurprisingly, the internet cannot handle Netflix's latest dating reality show.
By Neha Prakash
Isa Mazzei's New Memoir Shows the Dark and Illuminating Sides of Life as a 'Camgirl'
A must-read memoir by former camgirl, Isa Mazzei, known for last year's Netflix thriller, 'Cam,' is a tour of the internet's darker corners.
By Carl Kelsch