Marie Claire
  • Celebrity
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Culture
  • Power
  • Nice Talk
  • Style at Large
  • More
    • Politics
    • Career & Money
    • Health & Fitness
    • Power Play
    • Travel
    • Promo Codes
    • Food & Cocktails
    • About Us
    • Subscribe
    • Sex & Love
  • Newsletter SIGN UP TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Marie Claire
    Marie Claire Newsletter

    The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.


    By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

    You are now subscribed

    Your newsletter sign-up was successful


    Want to add more newsletters?

    Marie Claire Daily

    Delivered daily

    Marie Claire Daily

    Get exclusive access to fashion and beauty trends, hot-off-the-press celebrity news, and more.

    Marie Claire Self Checkout

    Sent weekly on Saturday

    Marie Claire Self Checkout

    Exclusive access to expert shopping and styling advice from Nikki Ogunnaike, Marie Claire's editor-in-chief.

    Maire Claire Face Forward

    Once a week

    Maire Claire Face Forward

    Insider tips and recommendations for skin, hair, makeup, nails and more from Hannah Baxter, Marie Claire's beauty director.

    Livingetc

    Once a week

    Livingetc

    Your shortcut to the now and the next in contemporary home decoration, from designing a fashion-forward kitchen to decoding color schemes, and the latest interiors trends.

    Homes & Gardens

    Delivered Daily

    Homes & Gardens

    The ultimate interior design resource from the world's leading experts - discover inspiring decorating ideas, color scheming know-how, garden inspiration and shopping expertise.


    An account already exists for this email address, please log in.
    Trending
    • Early Black Friday
    • Sofia Franklyn
    • GUIZIO
    • Thanksgiving Outfits
    • 'The Body'
    • Deer Print
    1. Politics

    Behind the Scenes of the Controversy at the Women's March

    They organized the largest one-day protest in U.S. history—and then everything fell apart. On the third anniversary, Marie Claire talks to the leaders of the Women’s March to learn the truth behind the drama.

    By Hannah N Seligson
    Published 17 January 2020 In Features

    When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

    Women's March 2019 - Washington, DC
    (Image credit: Aaron J. Thornton)
    • Facebook
    • X
    • Pinterest
    Share this article
    Join the conversation
    Follow us
    Add us as a preferred source on Google
    Subscribe to our newsletter

    The first time Bob Bland and Tamika Mallory met, it was like an awkward blind date. They had been set up in November 2016 because of their early involvement in the Women’s March. During one of their first conversations, Bland, a white fashion designer known for her “Nasty Woman” T-shirt, asked Mallory, a black civil-rights activist, a question that still makes Bland cringe: “I don’t get it, what does racial justice have to do with women’s rights?”

    Reflecting on that question years later, Mallory says it was “very painful” to hear. “That was a moment when I didn’t know if I should continue with the Women’s March, because I knew Bob was willing to say what many others were thinking,” Mallory recalls. But instead of walking away, she kept talking, knowing the difficult work ahead hinged on uniting people from different backgrounds and differing views. “I tried to illustrate where I was coming from by describing how white women are very concerned about reproductive rights, whereas many black women are more concerned about socioeconomic inequality or gun violence, which is why many may not want to get pregnant in the first place. They are afraid the baby could be killed by a stray bullet,” she says.

    That vivid example clicked for Bland, spurring an examination of her white privilege and a desire to increase the visibility of women who have not been seen or heard. Today, Mallory and Bland, both of whom ended two-year terms on the board of the Women’s March, consider each other allies.

    Latest Videos FromMarie Claire
    Watch full video here:

    We were a random club of ladies who had never met, trying to organize this historic event in nine and a half weeks.

    The interaction between Bland and Mallory is reflective of the strange bedfellows—a chef, a yoga teacher, a film director, a poet, an herbalist—who came together to make history with the single largest one-day protest in U.S. history. “We were a random club of ladies who had never met, trying to organize this historic event in nine and a half weeks,” says Linda Sarsour, one of the original board members of the Women’s March. Many had no background in political organizing or activism.

    Three years after a mass of pink pussy hats descended on Washington, D.C., on January 21, 2017, the new guard—the recently appointed executive committee, which granted its first-ever interview to Marie Claire—has big shoes to fill. After all, this is a movement that packed trains and planes, gave Tarana Burke (the founder of the #MeToo movement) her first public platform, led to the arrest of nearly 600 women protesting family separation in D.C., spearheaded demonstrations during the Brett Kavanaugh hearings, and helped spark an unprecedented number of women to run for—and win—office in 2018. Yet despite such successes, the dominant narrative about the Women’s March has been of tensions and reported infighting among the organizers, with accusations of anti-Semitism splashed across headlines and on Twitter. But both the original founders and current organizers say the real behind-the-scenes story is much more complicated, nuanced, and, ultimately, hopeful than what has been told.

    You may like
    • Black-and-white portrait of Kathy Hochul and Adrienne Adams standing side by side and smiling at the camera. Can Two Women Take the Toxic Masculinity Out of New York Politics?
    • A group of executives, mostly men, sit around a long conference table, with white squares obscuring their faces. The Women Cracking Corporate America’s Most Exclusive Boys’ Club
    • collage of celebrities at the 2026 Victoria's Secret Fashion Show 2026 Victoria's Secret Fashion Show: Marie Claire Reacts to Every Can't-Miss Moment

    Crowd, People, Pink, Spring, Event, Flower, Public event, Plant, Audience, Tree,

    The Women’s March on Washington, the day after Donald J. Trump’s inauguration as president of the United States, in Washington DC on January 21, 2017.

    (Image credit: Benjamin Lowy)

    The day after President Donald Trump was elected, a Facebook post written by Teresa Shook, a grandmother in Hawaii, suggesting a women’s march on Washington, D.C., caught fire. Within the first 36 hours, two Facebook groups made up of primarily white women merged into what was originally called the Million Women March. Less than a week later, Sarsour and Mallory, along with Carmen Perez-Jordan, president of the Gathering for Justice, a racial-equality-focused nonprofit, were brought on by Michael Skolnik, Russell Simmons’s former political director, to add more diverse voices to the organization, which had been intensely criticized for being too homogenous.

    To say there was a lot of damage coming into the Women’s March is an understatement. There were disgruntled women from the Bernie Sanders campaign, depressed women from the Hillary Clinton campaign, terrified Muslims and Mexicans who had been targeted for months by Trump, and many women of color who felt betrayed by the 53 percent of white women who voted for him. Some of the leaders saw women’s rights through the lens of equal pay, paid leave, and abortion rights, while others pushed a broader view of tackling economic inequality, racial injustice, and climate change. These weren’t just open cuts but gaping, bleeding, raw wounds that a single one-day protest was never going to cauterize.

    Marie Claire Newsletter

    The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.

    By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

    The Women’s March movement, it could be argued, started after the march itself, when fired-up attendees wondered, What do we do now? The day after women took to the streets, Planned Parenthood and Emily’s List offered a four-hour course to train women how to run for office. The course sold out in nine minutes and had a 400-person wait list. Nine months later, a follow-up to the march, called the Women’s Convention, took place in Detroit, where 5,000 women gathered.

    Fashion, Formal wear, Little black dress, Event, Smile, Uniform,

    L to R: Tamika Mallory, Linda Sarsour, Bob Bland, and Carmen Perez-Jordan pose before the Mara Hoffman show during New York Fashion Week.

    (Image credit: Robin Marchant)

    While Trump may have united the Women’s March, another man, Louis Farrakhan, a minister with the Nation of Islam, led to its division. In 2001, when Mallory was a young mother of a toddler, her son’s father, Jason Ryans, was shot in Pennsylvania. Members of the Nation of Islam extended a hand to Mallory, who was raised a devout Christian, after his murder. The African American political and religious organization has deep anti-Semitic and anti-LGBTQ roots, but as Adam Serwer noted in The Atlantic in 2018, it is also “a force in impoverished black communities—not simply as a champion of the black poor or working class, but of the black underclass.” Much of the Women’s March controversy spun from a video clip of Mallory at a Nation of Islam gathering called Saviours’ Day. “In that most difficult period of my life, it was the women of the Nation of Islam who supported me, and I have always held them close to my heart for that reason,” Mallory said in a statement in March 2018.

    These weren’t just open cuts but gaping, bleeding, raw wounds that a single one-day protest was never going to cauterize.

    That, in a nutshell, is how Farrakhan, who has been called an anti-Semite by the Anti-Defamation League, came to be inextricably associated with the Women’s March. Perez-Jordan, too, was criticized for her past support of Farrakhan. Then came accusations of anti-Semitism against Sarsour, who is a supporter of the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions movement against Israel. Bland also found herself a target of criticism when, in March 2019, she shared someone else’s Facebook post that criticized the Jewish community in connection with the Christchurch, New Zealand, mosque shooting. (Bland apologized and clarified that she did not agree with the original post.) The women publicly denied allegations of anti-Semitism but say it felt like no one was listening. “I want to be clear that our movement is a safe place for Jewish women,” Perez-Jordan says. “I have always rejected anti-Semitism, and I am intensely proud of our inclusive, intersectional movement for women’s liberation, [which] exists to fight bigotry and discrimination in all forms.”

    What to read next
    • Lake Rucker, Jasmine Goode, Venita Aspen, and Mia Calabrese staring at the camera What It's Like to Be Black and On Bravo
    • A portrait of Jessica Tarlov seated outdoors in a teal pantsuit. Fox News’s Favorite Nasty Woman
    • Megan Thee Stallion Megan Thee Stallion's Reign Check

    Smile,

    Women’s March co-chairwoman Tamika Mallory during the Women’s March "Power to the Polls" voter registration tour launch.

    (Image credit: Ethan Miller)

    In a November 2019 interview, Mallory acknowledges the initial language of the Women’s March should have been more inclusive to Jewish women but sticks with her original defense, saying she did not condemn Farrakhan because she does not “believe in denouncing black people in America.” The conditions for black people in the U.S. “are way too challenged and difficult for other black women, particularly, to be denouncing black men, and that was the charge that was demanded of me,” Mallory says. With hindsight, she sees much of the controversies as “the right wing hoodwinking liberal white women.”

    “Look, there were very reasonable questions in light of my relationship with the Nation of Islam, and everyone had the right to ask what happened, but the mass-media machine that descended really was out to destroy the Women’s March,” Mallory says, referring to the barrage of negative coverage and personal attacks from right-wing outlets like the Daily Caller, which circulated a false claim that Sarsour has ties to the terrorist organization Hamas.

    As recently as September 2019, Breitbart News, which practically has a beat dedicated to denigrating the Women’s March, ran a story headlined “Women’s March Boots Linda Sarsour for Antisemitism, Keeps Pro-Farrakhan Carmen Perez.” According to the women, that headline is patently false: No one was booted. Sarsour, along with Bland and Mallory, came to the end of sanctioned two-year terms. The trio remains close to this day. Sarsour calls Perez-Jordan and Mallory her best friends, and she works closely with them on social-justice issues.

    Gilt.com & Women's March Celebrate International Women's Day With Roller Disco Launch Party

    Sarah Sophie Flicker at a Gilt.com & Women’s March International Women’s Day roller disco launch party.

    (Image credit: Cindy Ord)

    The relentless faultfinding against the Women’s March made Sarah Sophie Flicker, one of the original organizers, want to disappear into an underground bunker. “The press became distorted and overly focused on the negative, so I had a lot of reluctance to participate in another conversation about the Women’s March,” says Flicker, speaking on the record for the first time in over a year. “I could not live with myself if I contributed to the narrative that intersectional organizing doesn’t work.” She’s baffled that the Women’s March became such a target. “There are actual Nazis and white supremacists marching in the streets and holding power in the White House,” Flicker says. “My discomfort around the discourse is that instead of focusing our ire and condemnation at the real monsters, the narrative focused on a group of women of color.”

    We waded through really difficult, loving, and sometimes painful discussions. That's how change happens.

    The board underwent three trainings, primarily run through Jews for Racial & Economic Justice. Flicker, who says she identifies as white, Jewish, and privileged, feels the anti-Semitism allegations have been overly talked through and that the leadership really grappled with the crisis. “I am proud of the fact that we stayed in conversation with each other, learned about each other’s histories, and never gave up,” she says. “We waded through really difficult, loving, and sometimes painful discussions. In my estimation, that’s how change happens.”

    For those in the trenches, the fallout hasn’t been easy to digest. Mallory says “the repeated lies and smear campaign” took a toll. Sleeping pills failed her, and a doctor diagnosed her with post-traumatic stress disorder. Sarsour says she still has difficulty coming to grips with what she perceived to be an unfair and unrealistic standard for the Women’s March: “The idea that we all have to be united, where we all share the same agenda, the same issues, and agree on everything—it’s not possible,” says Sarsour, whose book, We Are Not Here to Be Bystanders: A Memoir of Love and Resistance, will be published in March. “We grew up differently. We come from different places.” She reiterated that conflict is often intrinsic to movement building. And movement building is really, really hard work.

    Mara Hoffman - Front Row & Backstage - February 2017 - New York Fashion Week: The Shows

    Linda Sarsour.

    (Image credit: Michael Stewart)

    Sarsour herself became a target of the hate that grew out of the Women’s March. In October 2018, two FBI agents knocked on her door to warn her about a man in Florida named Cesar Sayoc who had sent pipe bombs to Barack Obama, Joe Biden, and Clinton. When searching Sayoc’s house, the FBI found three addresses for Sarsour, along with a photograph of her. (Sayoc was sentenced to 20 years in prison.) “I have kids,” Sarsour says. “How do you explain to them, don’t touch the mail?” A lingering question for Sarsour: “Was the Women’s March obsessively scrutinized in a way that is actually dangerous and put many of our and our families’ lives at risk?”

    In September 2019, a new regime was put in place. Perez-Jordan stayed on as the only holdover from the original board. “We’ve all seen how our nation’s politics have changed in the last two years by electing female leaders of color who are committed to radical change,” Perez-Jordan says. “My goal for the Women’s March is to elect more progressive women in 2020 than ever before.” Rinku Sen, the new co-president, says she is very much looking toward the future. “We are going to be standing up against this vision of a white nationalist, homophobic country,” she says. “We are a new team, we’re all the way in, and people will judge us by our work.” For the 2020 Women’s March in Washington, D.C., on January 18, the organization is again planning on mobilizing millions of women to take to the streets across the country.

    Sen, formerly the executive director of the racial-justice organization Race Forward, who has 40 years’ experience in movement building and activism, is part of a new group of 16 board members. While the organization has no physical headquarters, the executive committee—Sen and Isa Noyola, former deputy director at the Transgender Law Center, are co-presidents; Lucy Flores, a former Nevada State assemblywoman, is treasurer; and Mrinalini Chakraborty, a political organizer working on immigrants’ and women’s rights, is the secretary—has weekly meetings via Zoom, and the full board meets virtually about once every six weeks.

    We are going to be standing up against this vision of a white nationalist, homophobic country.

    The organizers say they are in the process of rebooting to become less about the people at the top and more about the issues that unite its members and supporters. The new leaders acknowledge that the Women’s March, born out of the opposition to Trump, needs to evolve into something bigger and more far-reaching than opposing a single person. In other words, the Women’s March has to go from fighting Trump to fighting Trumpism—from being against someone to standing for something. “We need to demonstrate our collective power to end the policies of racism, sexism, and hate that come from this administration,” Flores says.

    They surveyed more than one million people on their email list three times during 2018 to understand what they wanted. The top issues that emerged—reproductive rights and health, immigration, and climate change—will be the focus moving forward. They also want to combat the normalization of sexual assault and sexism and lobby for laws to protect all gender identities.

    The coattails of the Women’s March are long. Not only did the organization catalyze the largest political movement in at least a generation, but many progressive wins during the Trump era could be seen as stemming from that first march in 2017: the 126 female members of Congress, the highest number in U.S. history; the expansion of Medicaid in Idaho in April 2019; flipping the Virginia Legislature just last fall. The real test for the Women’s March, however, won’t come until January 2021, when they will be marching either in support of or opposition to the president. Get your hats ready.

    This story appears in the February 2020 issue of Marie Claire.

    subscribe here

    RELATED STORIES

    Fashion, T-shirt, Cool, Street fashion, Outerwear, Jacket, Font, Crowd, Top, Street,

    (Image credit: Getty Images)

    The Most Powerful Signs From Immigration Marches

    Ear, Hat, Mammal, Pink, Crowd, Fashion accessory, Headgear, Public event, Sun hat, Protest,

    (Image credit: Getty Images)

    A Look at Women's Marches Around the World

    Explore More
    feminism
    Hannah N Seligson
    Read more
    Black-and-white portrait of Kathy Hochul and Adrienne Adams standing side by side and smiling at the camera.
    Politics Can Two Women Take the Toxic Masculinity Out of New York Politics? Governor Kathy Hochul and Adrienne Adams are making a case for a different kind of political power. In an exclusive joint interview with Marie Claire, the duo behind New York’s first all-woman ticket pull back the curtain.
    By Noor Ibrahim
    A group of executives, mostly men, sit around a long conference table, with white squares obscuring their faces.
    Career advice The Women Cracking Corporate America’s Most Exclusive Boys’ Club A growing network of dinners, boot camps, and five-figure intensives promises to get more women into the boardroom. Is it working?
    By Noor Ibrahim
     
     
    collage of celebrities at the 2026 Victoria's Secret Fashion Show
    Fashion 2026 Victoria's Secret Fashion Show: Marie Claire Reacts to Every Can't-Miss Moment
    By Meguire Hennes
    a black and white headshot of composer missy mazzoli looking to the side plastered over an image of red seats in an opera house
    Music I'm Making Opera History. Women in Punk Got Me Here Composer Missy Mazzoli shares an essay about her early inspirations, as 'Lincoln in the Bardo' premieres at the Met.
    By Missy Mazzoli
     
     
    Latest in Politics
    a collage of fiction and nonfiction books to read after the midterms to continue inspiring hope including people's project out time is now and more
    Books Hope Is Back After the 2026 Midterms—10 Books to Sustain It Into 2027
    Black-and-white portrait of Kathy Hochul and Adrienne Adams standing side by side and smiling at the camera.
    Politics Can Two Women Take the Toxic Masculinity Out of New York Politics?
     
     
    Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans walk together outdoors, with Holmes looking toward the camera.
    Movies Does Elizabeth Holmes’s Fiancé Want to Be Elizabeth Holmes?
    a split image of author elena dudum resting her head on her chin and the cover of her memoir they told me back home would be beautiful
    Books My Father Spent Years Collecting Proof That Palestine Existed. Then He Gave It All to Me
     
     
    Latest in Features
    collage of champagne nails with gold detailing, côte polish, pink lilac chrome manicure, Gelcare polish, mixed metallic French tips and gold Chanel nail polish
    Nails Champagne Shimmer and Chrome Nails Are All Over My Mani Mood Board
    loulu hawaii vitamin c pod power duo in green bottles, a serum texture, and the skincare pod in a palm
    Skincare I Played Chemist With a Vitamin C Serum That's Made On the Spot
     
     
    green background with girls using lavanae skincare
    Skincare Thanks to This New Ayurvedic Skincare Brand, My Stubborn Redness Is Finally Gone
    GUIZIO Heaven Knows perfume collage, pink bottle with frosted angel wing cap between photos of a blonde model holding it, pastel clouds in the background
    Fragrance GUIZIO Bottled Its Cool-Girl Appeal In a Perfume—and I’m Buying Whatever She’s Selling
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    Marie Claire
    RSS
    • About us
    • Contact Future's experts
    • Contact us
    • Advertise Online
    • Newsletter
    • Terms and conditions
    • Privacy policy
    • Cookies policy
    • Careers
    Add as a preferred source on Google Add as a preferred source on Google

    Marie Claire is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

    © Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.