What 'American Murder: The Family Next Door' Left Out About the Chris Watts Murders

The documentary missed a few key details in the grisly case.

american murder the family next door
(Image credit: Shanann Watts/Netflix/2020)

Ever since American Murder: The Family Next Door (opens in new tab) arrived on Netflix at the end of September, transfixed viewers have searched high and low for every possible bit of information about Chris Watts. They've started Reddit threads, tweeted out increasingly ludicrous theories, and, in general, spent hours scouring the internet for even the tiniest details about Watts' crimes that didn't make it into the documentary's 82 minutes of footage.

To recap: Watts is currently serving five life sentences (opens in new tab) in a maximum-security prison in Wisconsin after killing his wife Shan'ann, who was 15 weeks pregnant at the time of her death, and their two daughters in Aug. 2018. Watts initially claimed he'd had no involvement in his wife and daughters' disappearances, but his story fell apart in a matter of days, and he was ultimately convicted of their murders.

Obviously, it would be nearly impossible to include every single detail about Chris, Shan'ann, their relationship, the murders, and their aftermath in a single documentary. So, here, find several key points that were left out of American Murder—it can't hurt to have a little extra context before you settle in for yet another rewatch.

Shan'ann and Chris Watts struggled financially

The couple filed for bankruptcy in 2015, court documents show, CNN (opens in new tab) reported shortly after Chris' arrest. At the time, they had just purchased a $400,000 house and were about $70,000 in combined student loan and credit card debt. The documents show that Chris was the family's primary breadwinner, taking in about $63,000 of their joint income of $91,000.

However, in 2018, Shan'ann started a new job with a lifestyle company. She received a major salary boost, began driving a Lexus, and was sent on paid business trips to places like Mexico and the Dominican Republic, leaving Chris at home to take care of their daughters. It's unclear how Shan'ann's sudden financial success affected her marriage, but with her out of town more often, Chris began secretly dating a colleague, Nichol Kessinger.

american murder the family next door

(Image credit: Shanann Watts/Netflix/2020)

Nichol Kessinger helped put Chris Watts behind bars

While the documentary seems to theorize that Chris killed his family so he could be with Kessinger, it skims over the extent of her involvement (opens in new tab) in the criminal investigation. The geologist, who has said she didn't know Chris was still married when they began dating in July 2018, called and questioned him when she learned about his family's disappearance from the news. Once she learned the extent of his lies and felt that his responses to his questions "seemed off," Kessinger immediately approached investigators to share everything she knew about Chris.

Kessinger, who is now living a quiet life under the radar, quickly became convinced of his guilt, telling The Denver Post a few months later, "He's a liar. He lied about everything. ... If he was able to lie to me and hide something that big, what else was he lying about?"

Kessinger's information was crucial to the investigation. In a 2019 Investigation Discovery interview (opens in new tab), Weld County District Attorney Michael Rourke said, "Nichol Kessinger turned out to have information that I can best describe as being a bombshell."

where is nichol kessinger, girlfriend of chris watts, now

(Image credit: RJ Sangosti)

Chris Watts has revealed more about the murders from prison.

Trigger warning: Disturbing details about attempted murder. During his time at the Dodge Correctional Institution (opens in new tab) in Waupun, Wisconsin, Chris has reportedly maintained correspondence with family members and some strangers, including Cheryln Cadle, who published many of their letters in a book called Letters From Christopher: The Tragic Confessions of the Watts Family Murders in 2019. In several of the letters (opens in new tab), Chris offered insight into his mindset at the time of the murders, as well as grisly new details about the crimes.

For one thing, he wrote that he knew he was going to kill his wife and daughters well before doing so. After putting his children to bed the night before, he wrote, "I walked away and said, 'That's the last time I'm going to be tucking my babies.'" Of Shan'ann's death, he wrote in another letter, "All the weeks of me thinking about killing her, and now I was faced with it."

Elsewhere in the letters, Chris revealed that, although he first attempted to smother his daughters in their beds before returning to his bedroom to kill Shan'ann, the two girls somehow "woke back up." "It makes the act that much worse knowing I went to their rooms first and knowing I still took their lives at the location," he continued, referring to the oil storage facility where he worked and where he hid the three bodies.

Finally, in one of the letters, Chris seemingly confirmed the theory that he killed his wife and daughters in order to be with Kessinger. He admitted that he had slipped Oxycodone to Shan'ann to try to cause her to miscarry, explaining to Cadle, "I thought it would be easier to be with Nichol if Shan'ann wasn't pregnant."

Andrea Park is a Chicago-based writer and reporter with a near-encyclopedic knowledge of the extended Kardashian-Jenner kingdom, early 2000s rom-coms and celebrity book club selections. She graduated from the Columbia School of Journalism in 2017 and has also written for W, Brides, Glamour, Women's Health, People and more.