By Andrea Park
Content warning: Police brutality; suicide.
Well into their sixth straight month of striking and protesting, farmers in India continue to demand the repeal of three recently passed agricultural bills that they believe prioritize corporate interests over their own. The protests began in August when the three bills were first unveiled and have continued to grow exponentially as the bills were passed in September. The government has repeatedly refused to grant the demands of farmers and agricultural unions in subsequent meetings.
The protest, at its core, reflects global issues of workers' rights and labor regulations and the Indian government's treatment of the protestors has begun to veer dangerously into human rights violation territory, but it still has not been covered widely outside of India (even as people around the world have hosted their own protests in solidarity). That changed, however, when the peaceful protests turned violent at the end of January. On Jan. 26, India's Republic Day, farmers hosting a planned rally drove their tractors into Delhi's city center and stormed the capital's historic Red Fort, where they clashed with police armed with tear gas, batons, and assault rifles. According to the BBC, one protestor died and more than 300 police officers were injured in the clash; more than 200 protestors were subsequently detained, as were eight working journalists, per Human Rights Watch.
In early February, after the Indian government was reported to be restricting internet access in the areas around the ongoing protests, global activists like Rihanna began using their platforms to signal-boost the farmers' cause.
why aren’t we talking about this?! #FarmersProtest https://t.co/obmIlXhK9SFebruary 2, 2021
We stand in solidarity with the #FarmersProtest in India. https://t.co/tqvR0oHgo0February 2, 2021
A photo posted by on
As the protest nears the six-month mark, the government shows no sign of accepting the protestors' demands and therefore has all but ensured their continued civil disobedience. Here's a primer on the ongoing conflict.
What sparked the farmers' protest?
The farmers' protest is centered around conflict over three pieces of agricultural legislation passed in September by India's Parliament with support from Prime Minister Narendra Modi. According to PRS, a nonprofit Indian legislative research institute, the three bills decrease trade regulations on farmers' goods, allow for online and interstate trading, enable farmers and buyers to enact exclusive contracts, and limit the government's ability to regulate the supply of essential commodities.
The bills were presented by Modi and other legislative supporters as giving farmers more freedom to control their own trade and expand their own markets. The farmers, however, argue that the increased competition enabled by this deregulation will give corporate buyers, rather than agricultural workers—who make up nearly 60 percent of India's population—all the power. Since the buyers will have access to a wider pool of suppliers, they'll therefore be able to drive down prices, a phenomenon further compounded by the bills' removal of government-imposed minimum prices for certain goods, which farmers say were already only barely helping them scrape by.
Since the protests started in August, ahead of the bills' passage, dozens of protestors have died from severe weather conditions, health conditions such as heart attacks, car accidents while approaching the protests, and suicide, according to Al Jazeera.
What do the protestors want?
In short, a complete repeal of the three acts. Representatives from more than 30 agricultural unions that oppose the bills have met with government officials in 11 rounds of talks, to no avail. Officials have invited the farmers to participate in mediation, negotiation, and amendment of the laws, but the farmers have refused, citing their demand that the bills be repealed outright.
"The government has the sharpest of brains working for it. The fact that they've not been able to come up with a proposal which meets our demands means that our case is strong," Kiran Vissa, a union member and a leader of the protests, told The Wire in December, noting that merely amending any of the bills would nullify the others. "So the only way the demands can be met is by a complete repeal of the laws. The government has refused to look into the nature of our demands in a substantive manner."
The nation's Supreme Court issued an order in mid-January suspending the bills and appointing a committee to oversee future negotiations, The Guardian reported. The protestors continued to stand by their request for a total cancellation of the legislation, rather than an unsatisfactory compromise, with leaders reportedly saying, "Now is not the time for a committee."
In response to the suspension order, Bhog Singh Mansa, President of the Indian Farmers Union, echoed Vissa's sentiments. "A stay is not a solution. We are here to get these laws scrapped completely," he told the Business Standard. "The government has in a way already agreed to scrap the laws when it said it is willing to incorporate as many amendments as farmers want."
What has the government said and done?
In the most recent round of talks on Jan. 22, the government said its best offer was a suspension of the bills for up to 18 months, which the farmers once again rejected, as it doesn't meet their explicit demands. After hitting this roadblock, per The Print, the groups have yet to schedule their next round of talks.
In earlier talks, government officials said they had reached a consensus with the protestors on the issues of decriminalizing necessary controlled fires and dropping a provision that increased power tariffs—though, once again, they stopped far short of agreeing to completely repeal the laws. Officials have labeled this refusal to accept anything less than repeal a sign "that these leaders are not going for a solution—they are continuously wanting to create a movement against the government," Gopal Krishna Agarwal, a spokesperson for Modi's Bharatiya Janata Party, told The New York Times.
Throughout the months of protests, supporters of the laws have also claimed that the farmers simply do not understand their provisions, with Modi reportedly blaming the protests on a misinformation campaign by the opposition party. However, the lack of tangible results from the 11 rounds of talks, plus growing evidence of misinformation being spread by the bills' supporters, prove that the protests are based not on a misunderstanding, but on a fundamental disagreement over the rights and treatment of agricultural workers.
Additionally, on Jan. 26, after the Republic Day violence, the interior ministry announced that it was suspending mobile internet services in several districts surrounding Delhi, where hundreds of thousands of farmers have been camped out for months, the BBC reported. The shutdown was supposed to last only for a few hours, but has been repeatedly extended each day, according to CNN, with officials claiming that the internet shutdowns—essentially cutting off the farmers' ability to share and receive information—was "in the interest of maintaining public safety and averting public emergency."
With the bills' supporters continued refusal to accept the farmers' demands of total repeal, and no further talks on the schedule, it seems likely that the protests will stretch on for weeks, if not months, though many of the farmers may choose to return to their farms when planting season begins in March.
"We are not going back—that is not in our genetic code," Ringhu Yaspal, a protestor camped outside of Delhi, told The New York Times in the days after the Republic Day clash. "Agriculture has turned into a slow poison. It's better to die fighting here."
Also in the camps, Jagtar Singh Bajwa, a farm leader, told an assembled crowd, "We should not give a message that we are tired, that we are going home," according to the Times, adding, "We will start over today, with full unity."
Andrea Park is a Chicago-based writer and reporter with a near-encyclopedic knowledge of the extended Kardashian-Jenner kingdom, early 2000s rom-coms and celebrity book club selections. She graduated from the Columbia School of Journalism in 2017 and has also written for W, Brides, Glamour, Women's Health, People and more.
The 'True Story' Cast: Your Guide
Meet the cast of Netflix's latest thriller.
By Quinci LeGardye •
93 Gifts for Anyone and Everyone on Your List
A whole lot of gifts that will please everyone on your list.
By Maria Ricapito •
'Only Murders in the Building' Season 2: Everything We Know
The next season of the Hulu hit comedy will go in a "bigger direction."
By Neha Prakash •
Cory Booker and Rosario Dawson's Relationship Is No More
After three years of dating, the power couple have decided they're better off as friends.
By Marie Claire Editors •
Education for Women and Girls Is Crucial for Climate Justice
In an excerpt from her new book, 'A Bigger Picture,' Ugandan climate activist Vanessa Nakate discusses the impact educated African women and girls can have on solving the climate crisis.
By Vanessa Nakate •
It’s Time to End Equal Pay Days and Pass the Equal Rights Amendment
The passage of the ERA is a chance for our country to prove it truly values women.
By Hala Ayala •
In Conversation: Secretary Jennifer Granholm and Emily Tisch Sussman
“It’s ridiculous that we’re the only advanced nation on the planet that doesn’t help families with childcare.”
By Emily Tisch Sussman •
EMILY's List President Laphonza Butler Has Big Plans for the Organization
Under Butler's leadership, the largest resource for women in politics aims to expand Black political power and become more accessible for candidates across the nation.
By Rachel Epstein •
Anita Hill Believes We Can End Gender Violence
Three decades after her landmark testimony in the Clarence Thomas confirmation hearings, the esteemed professor and lawyer has a message for leaders: The time is now to prioritize anti-gender violence policies.
By Rachel Epstein •
For Teachers, Going to Work Can Mean Life or Death
Stefanie Minguell, a COVID survivor and second grade teacher in Florida's Broward County, almost died of COVID-19 and is immunocomprised. When she teaches in the classroom, she’s forced to choose between her health and her students.
By Megan DiTrolio •
Periods Don’t Stop for Pandemics—And Neither Have Our Nation’s Moms
Policies touted in the $3.5 trillion budget plan and other Congressional bills are missing a core component of maternal well-being: menstrual access and health.
By Christy Turlington Burns •