Marie Claire
  • Newsletter SIGN UP TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Newsletter SIGN UP TO OUR NEWSLETTER
    • Celebrity
    • Fashion
    • Beauty
    • Culture
    • Power
    • Nice Talk
    • Style at Large
    • More
      • Politics
      • Career & Money
      • Health & Fitness
      • Power Play
      • Travel
      • Promo Codes
      • Food & Cocktails
      • About Us
      • Subscribe
      • Sex & Love
    Marie Claire
    Marie Claire Newsletter

    The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.


    By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

    You are now subscribed

    Your newsletter sign-up was successful


    Want to add more newsletters?

    Marie Claire Daily

    Delivered daily

    Marie Claire Daily

    Get exclusive access to fashion and beauty trends, hot-off-the-press celebrity news, and more.

    Marie Claire Self Checkout

    Sent weekly on Saturday

    Marie Claire Self Checkout

    Exclusive access to expert shopping and styling advice from Nikki Ogunnaike, Marie Claire's editor-in-chief.

    Maire Claire Face Forward

    Once a week

    Maire Claire Face Forward

    Insider tips and recommendations for skin, hair, makeup, nails and more from Hannah Baxter, Marie Claire's beauty director.

    Livingetc

    Once a week

    Livingetc

    Your shortcut to the now and the next in contemporary home decoration, from designing a fashion-forward kitchen to decoding color schemes, and the latest interiors trends.

    Homes & Gardens

    Delivered Daily

    Homes & Gardens

    The ultimate interior design resource from the world's leading experts - discover inspiring decorating ideas, color scheming know-how, garden inspiration and shopping expertise.


    An account already exists for this email address, please log in.
    Trending
    • Cashmere Scarves
    • Beauty Launches
    • 'The Body'
    • Cocoon Jeans
    • Deer Print
    • Plastic Surgery Week
    1. Culture

    Hannah Horvath Should Have Had an Abortion

    The Girls writers failed their protagonist.

    Valentina Valentini's avatar
    By Valentina Valentini
    Published 14 April 2017 In News

    When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

    People in nature, Bag, Beauty, Street fashion, Photo shoot, Portrait photography, Model,
    (Image credit: HBO)
    • Facebook
    • X
    • Pinterest
    Share this article
    Join the conversation
    Follow us
    Add us as a preferred source on Google
    Subscribe to our newsletter

    If you've been following the final season of Girls, you've probably noticed that the 20-something, single, semi-employed Hannah Horvath has chosen to keep her baby. Which is 1,000 percent her decision. But maybe it's not the right decision.

    It took me by surprise and—as a fellow feminist—even made me a bit angry that a young woman on the cusp of so much (who is being written by a young woman who's already accomplished so much) would stop everything to do the thing young women have been doing in movies and TV for so many years: have a baby they didn't choose to have in the first place.

    Despite the Trumpian world we live in, women do have a choice. We can choose to get an IUD (I did). We can chose to plan a pregnancy. And we can (for the time being) choose to abort one when life throws us a curveball. These are all rights that are currently in the crosshairs. It is, no doubt, a scary time to be a woman in America. So why would the very progressive, very outspoken, very frequent "voice of our generation" back away from what this moment could be: a major opportunity to highlight, advocate for, and—as Lena Dunham has done through her show so successfully so many times—spark a serious and necessary discussion about what really matters?

    Latest Videos FromMarie Claire
    Watch full video here:

    Like many Girls viewers, I've always connected with Hannah on a personal level, whether she's her painfully messy self or her optimistically ambitious one. Her character has been, up until now, so complicated, unapologetic, and surprising that it makes her feel, in many ways, real. Which is why it saddens me to watch her suddenly become so flat—to go through with a pregnancy just because, to quote her own rationale, why not now?

    I get that this might not be a popular opinion, but when it comes to narrative accuracy, popular opinion feels like a moot point. Never mind the fact that unexpected motherhood is the most played-out trope on TV. There are just so many reasons this was a disappointing narrative choice, and that the Girls creators should have written the story so that Hannah got an abortion instead, like...

    You may like
    • a split image of author carola lovering wearing a black blouse and posing outside in front of a tree opposite the cover of her thriller novel whiteout Four Years Ago, a Tragedy Stayed With Me. Then I Wrote a Novel.
    • Harry Jowsey wears a tuxedo shirt while speaking with a woman in a wedding veil, in a still from the 'Let's Marry Harry' finale. We No Longer Think Marriage Is a "Prize." Why Do Netflix Dating Shows?
    • A collage featuring a black sculptural vase against a torn white paper backdrop, with delicate red flowers and green stems spilling over the edge. The Hidden Costs of Miscarriage

    It Makes More Sense for Her Character.

    Hannah isn't someone who makes you think, "Wow, what a put-together person." She makes reckless decisions on a whim, she can't multi-task, and her short stints of employment are usually followed by longer stints of unemployment, gross procrastination, and general antipathy about what she wants to be when she "grows up." This doesn't make Hannah unlovable or a bad person, but it does make her a product of her generation, of being white, and of being privileged. She shouldn't be shunned for it. In fact, Hannah's imperfections make for quite a compelling TV show—as the popularity of Girls proves.

    The thing is, Hannah is also incredibly self-aware. We know she's not particularly capable of taking care of another person, so why doesn't she know it?

    Marie Claire Newsletter

    The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.

    By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

    The Rationale for Her Choosing to Keep the Baby Is Actually Pretty Anti-Feminist.

    When Marnie argues that motherhood will give Hannah "somebody else to consider," she's projecting an idealized scenario where bringing a human baby into the world "sets a woman straight." This is a tired trope, and one that implies women need babies to fix them, make them better, or make them complete.

    Event, Fashion, Fun, Temple, Fashion design,

    (Image credit: HBO)

    It's Narratively Lazy.

    The final episodes of Girls—while praised for being its best thus far—seem surprisingly uncomplicated for a show that's known for its nuanced character development. Plot lines are already being wrapped up in pretty bows, as so often happens in final seasons, and Hannah's pregnancy is no different. Sure, the pregnancy itself might be realistic, but the decision to keep the baby when so much of Hannah's life is a huge question mark comes off as a cheap way to redeem her of her transgressions.

    "I know I want a baby someday, so why not make someday now?" Hannah muses at one point to her on-again-off-again-finally-totally-off-again boyfriend Adam on the banks of the Hudson.

    What to read next
    • alexis bledel and lauren graham as rory and lorelai sitting outside at an autumnal table in gilmore girls 30 Fast-Talking, Quirky-Character-Filled Shows to Watch After 'Gilmore Girls'
    • stassi schroeder gets her hair and makeup done in a robe in a still from house of stassi Why Is Reality TV Suddenly Breaking the Fourth Wall?
    • A collage of production photos from the play 'The Peterson Show,' with a portrait of playwright Janine Nabers at the center. I've Found Comedy Is Cheaper Than Therapy

    Fair, but is "someday" happening now because it makes sense for Hannah as a human, or because the writers have to find a way to bring things to a close?

    Not Enough Abortions Are Shown on TV.

    There is still a very real and very hurtful stigma about women who choose to abort pregnancies, and there's a clear way to help put an end to it: Expose more people to their plights. Make more Americans aware of women's experiences—and the real, raw, emotional reality that goes with them—and you make more empathetic Americans.

    While Girls has tackled the subject of abortion before (Jessa scheduled one in the first season—but, in another avoidance of the issue, it never happened because her character realized she wasn't actually pregnant), this time HBO and Dunham don't find themselves on that progressive bandwagon—which just seems so off when you consider the type of woman Dunham's been trying to portray this entire time.

    Through Hannah, Girls could have pushed boundaries and sent a powerful message that sometimes choosing an abortion is the mature thing—even if it doesn't feel like it. That has to be a better ending than "life's a mess, might as well have a baby," right?

    - YouTube  - YouTube
    Watch On

    We're nominated for a Webby Award—but we need your vote to win! Vote for the Women and Guns project here.

    Explore More
    pregnancy
    Valentina Valentini
    Valentina Valentini

    Valentina Valentini (yes, that's her real name) is a freelance journalist writing about movies, TV, travel, food and humans (herself included) for Vanity Fair, Los Angeles Times, Variety, New York Magazine and more

    Read more
    A collage featuring a black sculptural vase against a torn white paper backdrop, with delicate red flowers and green stems spilling over the edge.
    Money The Hidden Costs of Miscarriage
    By Hannah Summerhill
    Kristina Bogic as Anya, Sara Boustany as Elise, Emily Roman as Claire in angel devil and nun halloween costumes at a party in the body
    TV shows 'The Body' Creator Quinn Shephard Made a Divine TV Show For "the Tumblr Era Girls" The showrunner unpacks everything on her mood board that inspired the Netflix Y2K-set teen horror series.
    By Sadie Bell
     
     
    alaska riley miss benny and saturn risin9 pose against a white brick wall in an apartment while taking a photo in the movie club kid
    Movies Meet the Real-Life It Girls Bringing Fierceness—And Heart—to 'Club Kid' Jordan Firstman tapped creatives Alaska Riley, Miss Benny, and Saturn Risin9 to star in his directorial debut.
    By Sadie Bell
    meghann fahy as charlie and rose byrne as sam looking at a document in the dark in the good daughter
    TV shows How 'The Good Daughter' Ending Resolves Its Crimes of the Past and Present Meghann Fahy and Rose Byrne star in the Peacock thriller based on a Karin Slaughter novel.
    By Jessica Derschowitz
     
     
    Latest in Culture
    The apartment building for Hulu's 'The Circle', with silhouettes of people inside each unit, and a segment of a green neon circle attached to the building. Two units have decals reading "Blocked" and "Alert!"
    TV shows 'The Circle' Has Moved to Hulu—Meet the Cast of Reality TV Alums and Viral Newcomers
    A photo of Nikki Ogunnaike with an inset photo of Meghann Fahy and text reading Money. Power. Style. Nice Talk with Nikki Ogunnaike
    Culture Meghann Fahy on Pushing Through the "Dark, Lonely" Years Before Her Breakthrough
     
     
    julia garner as caroline ellison walking through an office full of rows of computers in the altruists
    TV shows Where Is Caroline Ellison Now? What To Know About Her Life After 'The Altruists'
    l-r Bri Davis, Aspyn Ovard, Salomé Andrea, and Bobbi Althoff in Hulu's 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County.'
    TV shows MomTok Has Arrived in Orange County. Will the 'Mormon Wives' Spinoff Return for Season 2?
     
     
    Latest in News
    Princess Kate wearing a red dress
    Royals Princess Kate Has "Slowly Come to Terms" With One Aspect of Her Royal Life
    Princess Charlene and Princess Gabriella wearing matching ivory jackets
    Royals Princess Charlene Has a Mommy-and-Me Moment With Her 11-Year-Old Daughter
     
     
    Prince Harry wearing a gray polo shirt holding a mic
    Royals Prince Harry Says He'd Re-Enlist in the Army If Asked Amid Russia-Ukraine War
    Jennifer Lawrence's beloved Colby Pants from La Ligne are 50 percent off for Black Friday
    Celebrity Style Jennifer Lawrence's Favorite La Ligne Pants Just Got a 50% Discount
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    Marie Claire
    RSS
    • About us
    • Contact Future's experts
    • Contact us
    • Advertise Online
    • Newsletter
    • Terms and conditions
    • Privacy policy
    • Cookies policy
    • Careers
    Add as a preferred source on Google Add as a preferred source on Google

    Marie Claire is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

    © Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.