Last night, during a post-debate cocktail, I said it: "Martha for president."
"Martha," of course, refers to Martha Raddatz, the moderator of the vice presidential debate, who did such a good job forcing realtalk out of the two candidates that I wish she'd hold the position for the rest of the election. Between Joe Biden and Paul Ryan, there was no landslide winner. Biden did seem to dominate, coming out swinging with the energy missing from Obama's performance last week. He got in many jabs and one-liners (the word "malarkey" is enjoying new life today). Still, Ryan kept it cool, sticking to his talking points and coming off sincere next to Biden's incessant smirking.
But let's be real: The true winner was Raddatz.
A major subplot of the first Romney-Obama debate was the abysmal performance of moderator Jim Lehrer. Not only did he ask maddeningly general questions — "What are the differences between the two of you?" was repeated several times — he also allowed both Mitt Romney and Barack Obama to steamroll over him. The debate was disappointing (opens in new tab) to Obama fans, sure, but it was equally frustrating for journalists the world over.
Raddatz, on the other hand, was in complete control. "Let's move to Iran," she commanded — and they did. She pressed them to clarify their answers — "what does that mean, 'a bunch of stuff'?" she asked Biden when he used that phrase to describe one of Ryan's answers. (Actually, it was more like "sh-stuff." Bless Biden for almost cursing on national television...again.)
Raddatz cut the candidates off when they digressed. She dug into Biden about Ambassador Stevens' death, asking if it was "a massive intelligence failure." She refused to let Ryan evade a question about the GOP's plan to increase the defense budget. By the New York Times' Andrew Rosenthal's count (opens in new tab), she underlined that point six times. She looked him right in the eye and asked: "I want to know how you do the math and have this increase in defense spending?" The whole 90 minutes was downright Sorkin-esque, reminding me of that aggressive rendition (opens in new tab) of a mock debate on HBO's The Newsroom.
I wasn't crazy about how Raddatz framed abortion in terms of the candidates' personal and religious principles; haven't we heard enough from white dudes' private views on women's bodies? As Salon's Irin Carmon pointed out (opens in new tab), the question's framing omitted women from the equation right away. But she managed to cover taxes, the budget deficit, Medicare, Social Security, national security, and Afghanistan and still asked the abortion question before time ran out — the word "women" wasn't even uttered during last week's debate.
Let this be a lesson to hapless debate moderators, past and future: The two sides do better when you keep them in line.
Nona Willis Aronowitz is an editor and writer who thinks a lot about love, sex and politics. She tweets at @nona.
I Spent Hours Scrolling Nordstrom's Spring Sale—These 31 Pieces Are Worth Your Money
By Brooke Knappenberger
This Protein Treatment Can Save Your Curl Definition In A Single Use
Your hair, only stronger.
By Gabrielle Ulubay
Khloé Kardashian Does Not "Miss Her Old Face," She'll Have You Know
She looks great, which is not a reason to apologize.
By Iris Goldsztajn
5 Practical Things You Can Do to Protect Democracy
Advice from top celebrities and Michelle Obama herself.
By Erin Geiger Smith
Why the 2022 Midterm Elections Are So Critical
As we blaze through a highly charged midterm election season, Swing Left Executive Director Yasmin Radjy highlights rising stars who are fighting for women’s rights.
By Tanya Benedicto Klich
Yes, Caregiving Is Essential Infrastructure
President Biden’s American Families Plan is further proof that care is necessary for economic growth.
By Valerie Jarrett
Senator Hirono on Her Journey to the U.S. Senate and Having a "Heart of Fire"
At first glance, 'Heart of Fire' is a political memoir. At its core, it's an ode to a mother who changed her daughter's life.
By Rachel Epstein
To Her Stepchildren, Kamala Harris Is "Momala"
"They are my endless source of love and pure joy," she's said.
By Katherine J Igoe
Who Are Joe Biden's Grandchildren, Who Range from Seven Months Old to 26?
He has seven!
By Katherine J Igoe
Who Is Maya Harris, Kamala Harris' Super-Supportive Sister?
Maya worked for Hillary Clinton in 2016 as a senior advisor.
By Katherine J Igoe
The Child Care Crisis Will Worsen If We Reelect Trump
COVID-19 has exacerbated the crisis for women, people of color, and low-wage workers. The Trump administration shows no signs of prioritizing the issue amid the pandemic.
By Tammy Duckworth