Marie Claire
  • Celebrity
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Culture
  • Power
  • Nice Talk
  • Style at Large
  • More
    • Politics
    • Career & Money
    • Health & Fitness
    • Power Play
    • Travel
    • Promo Codes
    • Food & Cocktails
    • About Us
    • Subscribe
    • Sex & Love
  • Newsletter SIGN UP TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Marie Claire
    Marie Claire Newsletter

    The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.


    By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

    You are now subscribed

    Your newsletter sign-up was successful


    Want to add more newsletters?

    Marie Claire Daily

    Delivered daily

    Marie Claire Daily

    Get exclusive access to fashion and beauty trends, hot-off-the-press celebrity news, and more.

    Marie Claire Self Checkout

    Sent weekly on Saturday

    Marie Claire Self Checkout

    Exclusive access to expert shopping and styling advice from Nikki Ogunnaike, Marie Claire's editor-in-chief.

    Maire Claire Face Forward

    Once a week

    Maire Claire Face Forward

    Insider tips and recommendations for skin, hair, makeup, nails and more from Hannah Baxter, Marie Claire's beauty director.

    Livingetc

    Once a week

    Livingetc

    Your shortcut to the now and the next in contemporary home decoration, from designing a fashion-forward kitchen to decoding color schemes, and the latest interiors trends.

    Homes & Gardens

    Delivered Daily

    Homes & Gardens

    The ultimate interior design resource from the world's leading experts - discover inspiring decorating ideas, color scheming know-how, garden inspiration and shopping expertise.


    An account already exists for this email address, please log in.
    Trending
    • Early Black Friday
    • Sofia Franklyn
    • Plastic Surgery Week
    • Thanksgiving Outfits
    • 'The Body'
    • Deer Print
    1. Culture

    The Modern Motherhood Conflict

    In a controversial new book, firebrand French philosopher Elisabeth Badinter argues that modern motherhood is a throwback to the past—and has become a tyranny for women

    By Pamela Druckerman
    Published 19 April 2012 In News

    When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

    0512-motherlode-elisabeth-badinter-de.jpg
    (Image credit: Archives)
    • Facebook
    • X
    • Pinterest
    Share this article
    Join the conversation
    Follow us
    Add us as a preferred source on Google
    Subscribe to our newsletter

    TO ELISABETH BADINTER, educated women who become stay-at-home moms have lost their minds. She explains why in her latest book, The Conflict: How Modern Motherhood Undermines the Status of Women, which has sold more than 200,000 copies in France. An English translation hits U.S. shelves on April 24. Here, Badinter speaks with Pamela Druckerman, author of Bringing Up Bébé: One American Mother Discovers the Wisdom of French Parenting.

    MARIE CLAIRE: What's the problem with being a mother today?

    ELISABETH BADINTER: There's a feminism that was born in the 1980s in the United States that defines women through motherhood. I find this dangerous. From my point of view, motherhood is a choice, not an obligation.

    Latest Videos FromMarie Claire
    Watch full video here:

    MC: You've written about a "naturalist" strain to modern motherhood—breast-feeding on demand, natural childbirth, eco-friendly washable diapers, homemade baby food—that pushes women back into the home.

    EB: Unquestionably. The gains of the previous century—epidurals, bottle-feeding, disposable diapers—allowed women to reconcile their roles as mothers with the necessity of being financially independent. This 21st-century project of naturalism, which makes the female into an animal again, is a rejection of those gains.

    You may like
    • a split image of author carola lovering wearing a black blouse and posing outside in front of a tree opposite the cover of her thriller novel whiteout Four Years Ago, a Tragedy Stayed With Me. Then I Wrote a Novel.
    • Black-and-white three-panel collage of mothers holding and cuddling their babies. We Asked Women to Share Private Texts, Searches, and Notes From Their Darkest Postpartum Days
    • Princess Kate holding hands with Prince George and Prince Louis, wearing school uniforms Princess Kate Holds a Role the Public "Wouldn't Allow" Marie Antoinette to Be

    Homemade baby food is terrific if you know how to cook and have time to make it. But why demonize commercial baby food, which is balanced, quick, and accessible to fathers?

    While we're waiting for biodegradable diapers to reach the market, I would choose disposable diapers [instead of washable ones]. Between the protection of the environment and the protection of the liberty and free time of women, my choice is made.

    Marie Claire Newsletter

    The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.

    By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

    MC: You also point out that the amount of time women spend with their children has gone up enormously.

    EB: Absolutely. And the parents are less happy. They're always full of anxiety and guilt that they never do enough for their children. And I find that incompatible with the desires of women today. The majority of women in Western countries want to have economic independence, too.

    Also, life expectancy keeps increasing—85 years for women. And taking care of kids is just 18 years. What do we do after that, when the children leave? It's much too late to be able to make a living in the workplace.

    What to read next
    • Black-and-white portrait of Kathy Hochul and Adrienne Adams standing side by side and smiling at the camera. Can Two Women Take the Toxic Masculinity Out of New York Politics?
    • A photo of Nikki Ogunnaike with an inset photo of Melinda French Gates and text reading Money. Power. Style. Nice Talk with Nikki Ogunnaike Melinda French Gates Wants to End One of Medicine's Biggest Blind Spots
    • Stylized image of a woman at a desk holding papers, overlaid with pink, blue, and green tones. The Hidden Price Tag of Menopause

    MC: You write about an "intellectual dowry"—women who get a higher education but then stop working after they have children.

    EB: These women don't see beyond the next three years. I'm stupefied when I say to them, "If you completely quit working, do you think that in three years it's going to be easy to find an equivalent job?" And it's this absence of vision in the middle of their lives that I find infantile. I'll say it: infantile. It doesn't give me any pleasure to say that. And this intellectual dowry is all in the name of "I want to be a good mother."

    MC: Do you believe that it's good for children to have a mother who works?

    EB: Yes. Learning to get along without their mother is good for children. What's more, it's an excellent reason to further involve the father in caring for the child. For 30 years, the objective has been to involve the father in taking care of a baby, from birth. If the child becomes the mother's sole purpose, it discourages the father from participating.

    I'm also concerned about the effects of the long-term fusion between a mother and child beyond the first few months. I'm afraid that this fusion will impact children in a way that we can't measure today.

    MC: You've also spoken about how all-consuming motherhood affects couples' relationships. You write, "If the woman breast-feeds for months, even years, how is the couple to retain intimacy?"

    EB: If 24 hours a day the woman is reduced to her role as a nursing animal, even putting the child in the bed between the father and the mother, the father is completely put aside. I think this is very hard for men, and I think the child becomes a factor in the separation of the couple.

    Breast-feeding a few weeks, sometimes a few months, OK. But when it's recommended that you breast-feed your child for one year—six months exclusively, with nothing else, day and night, on demand—there are obvious consequences for a couple.

    Let women do what they want! There are women for whom breast-feeding is a true pleasure. It's very good for them and it's very good for the baby. But to breast-feed a baby if the mother doesn't herself like it? It's a catastrophe. The decision to breast-feed is an intimate and private decision. No one should be able to interfere.

    MC: Do you believe that the benefits of breast milk are exaggerated?

    EB: It's true that mother's milk is perfectly adapted to the needs of a child, and that it evolves according to the growth of the baby. It's excellent. But frankly, the formula manufactured today is almost as good. And if it's beneficial to the life of the mother, it's worth it to give a bottle. We should stop telling women that when they give a child a bottle they're bad mothers.

    MC: You write that French women have a long history of not giving up their identity as women when they become mothers.

    EB: Since the 18th century, the idea was that when you have a child, you become a mother. But you're not just a mother. Even when there's a child, first of all, you must have a satisfying sex life—that's an imperative.

    Something of that remains today. It's one of the genes of the French—the idea that when one is a mother, life doesn't stop, and that to be just a mother is not to be a fully realized woman. It's one part of your life. It's not your whole life.

    I find that attitude liberating. I don't want us to start sending off children to wet nurses again. I don't want to go back to that. But I think that some part of that break between the child and the mother works very well for me, it works very well for us. And I'd like to conserve that.

    MC: Do you have any advice for today's young women?

    EB: Don't ever give up your economic independence. Don't give up your job. You must be able to survive without a man. Because if you no longer get along with your partner or he treats you badly and you don't have the means to leave him, you're enslaved.

    Pamela Druckerman
    Read more
    Black-and-white portrait of Kathy Hochul and Adrienne Adams standing side by side and smiling at the camera.
    Politics Can Two Women Take the Toxic Masculinity Out of New York Politics? Governor Kathy Hochul and Adrienne Adams are making a case for a different kind of political power. In an exclusive joint interview with Marie Claire, the duo behind New York’s first all-woman ticket pull back the curtain.
    By Noor Ibrahim
    Princess Kate holding hands with Prince George and Prince Louis, wearing school uniforms
    Royals Princess Kate Holds a Role the Public "Wouldn't Allow" Marie Antoinette to Be
    By Kristin Contino
     
     
    A group of executives, mostly men, sit around a long conference table, with white squares obscuring their faces.
    Career advice The Women Cracking Corporate America’s Most Exclusive Boys’ Club A growing network of dinners, boot camps, and five-figure intensives promises to get more women into the boardroom. Is it working?
    By Noor Ibrahim
    Princess Diana wearing her black revenge dress
    Royals Exclusive: Royal Historian Says Princess Diana Tore the Royal Family's "Cinderella" Myth "to Pieces"
    By Kristin Contino
     
     
    Latest in Culture
    l-r Bri Davis, Aspyn Ovard, Salomé Andrea, and Bobbi Althoff in Hulu's 'The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives: Orange County.'
    TV shows MomTok Has Arrived in Orange County. Will the 'Mormon Wives' Spinoff Return for Season 2?
    A photo of Nikki Ogunnaike with an inset photo of Sofia Franklyn and text reading Money. Power. Style. Nice Talk with Nikki Ogunnaike
    Culture Sofia Franklyn's Advice for Anyone Going Through a Friendship Breakup
     
     
    a split image of author veronica roth's headshot and the cover of her divergent novel the sixth faction
    Books When the World Seems Grim, Veronica Roth Will Always Turn to Dystopian YA
    the radio city rockettes wear candy cane inspired outfits and dance in rockefeller center at the 2025 tree lighting
    TV shows Get Into the Holiday Spirit With These Christmas Specials Coming to TV Soon
     
     
    Latest in News
    Princess Kate swinging a cricket bat
    Royals Princess Kate Is "Letting Her Guard Down" During Mumbai Tour
    Jennifer Lawrence was spotted in New York City wearing sweatpants, Ugg boots, and a fur coat with a scarf
    Celebrity Style Jennifer Lawrence Just Made Sweatpants and Uggs Look Like a Chic Winter Outfit
     
     
    Princess Kate wearing a blue dress sitting next to Prince William on the Mumbai Metro with her handbag on the seat next to her
    Royals Princess Kate Has a Sustainable Surprise Up Her Sleeve With This Innovative Bag
    Rihanna styled striped Dries Van Noten ballet sneakers that matched her striped tote bag
    Celebrity Style Rihanna's Response to the White Sneaker Takeover? Striped Ballet Trainers
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    Marie Claire
    RSS
    • About us
    • Contact Future's experts
    • Contact us
    • Advertise Online
    • Newsletter
    • Terms and conditions
    • Privacy policy
    • Cookies policy
    • Careers
    Add as a preferred source on Google Add as a preferred source on Google

    Marie Claire is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

    © Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.