The 14 Best Drugstore Mascaras are Lash Extensions in a Bottle

Editors put budget-friendly formulas to the test.

beautiful model applying mascara
(Image credit: Getty Images)

I've spent more money than I care to admit on makeup—some of my favorite luxury moisturizers and serums can get pretty pricey (think: $200 and up). But, I take solace in knowing that not all beauty products will cost me a fortune. Case in point: the best drugstore mascaras.

It’s a well-known fact among editors and beauty fans alike that some of the best mascaras are incredibly affordable and available at CVS, Target, or Walgreens. I don't stray from my drugstore favorites (Maybelline Sky High Mascara for the win), but don't just trust me; take it from the pros. "I gravitate mainly towards drugstore mascaras because I find the formulas are some of the best out there," says celebrity makeup artist Shadi Malek.

Whether I'm hoping to achieve impossibly long lashes with a lengthening mascara or I'm planning a night out and need one of the best volumizing mascaras for a fluttery look, my collection has options. There are tubing mascaras, waterproof formulas, and wands narrow enough for my lower lash line—all under $15.

I've personally tested the best drugstore mascaras on the market, tapping drugstore brands like CoverGirl, Maybelline, and L'Oréal Paris, as well as few TikTok-made-me-buy-it picks. I've also spoken with Malek, along with makeup artist Natalie Dresher, to learn the best application tips (yes, there's a way to prevent smudging) and what to look for in a stellar formula and mascara wand.

The Best Drugstore Mascaras

natlie dresher trying mascara

Natalie Dresher wearing Mcobeauty Xtendlash Mascara

(Image credit: Natalie Dresher)

writer trying a drugstore mascara

Jamie Wilson wearing Maybelline New York Sky High mascara

(Image credit: MC Writer)

writer trying a drugstore mascara

Shawna Hudson wearing essence Lash Princess mascara

(Image credit: MC Writer)

writer trying a drugstore mascara

Nykia Spradley wearing Covergirl Simply Ageless Plumping Mascara

(Image credit: MC Writer)

Other Drugstore Mascaras I Love

What Do I Look for in a Drugstore Mascara?

  • Formula

Start your search for the best drugstore mascara by deciding how you want your lashes to look like. If you're after volume, a mascara formula with added fibers will help build out your lashes in fewer swipes. You can also restore brittle lashes with a conditioning formula with nourishing oils and peptides. For a smudge-free formula, seek out a tubing mascara.

  • Brush Type

The magic in a mascara is often found in the brush head. There's a reason why mascara wands come in such a wide range of shapes, densities, and materials. Chunkier brushes will help stack on the volume, curved ones will help lift straighter lashes, and skinny or tapered wands are where you'll get maximum definition.

  • Waterproof

Maybe you're wearing makeup in a sweaty climate or to the beach and want it to stay put. Or perhaps you just prefer a formula that won't budge no matter what the day throws at you. Either way, a waterproof formula will deliver smudge, tear, and general wear resistance until you're ready to wash it off with a face cleanser.

But that doesn't mean waterproof is always best. If you want an option that's easy to remove, look for a non-waterproof formula.

How Do I Apply Drugstore Mascara?

Just because a mascara is from the drugstore doesn't change how it's applied. Always start with clean, makeup-free lashes. Start from the underside of your lash line and glide the wand through your lash hairs from root to tip. Depending on the formula, you may only need one coat. If you want more volume or definition, give it another swipe from root to tip. Don't forget to do the same on your bottom lashes.

Meet the Experts

Portrait of Shadi Malek
Shadi Malek

With just under a decade of experience in the makeup industry, Shadi Malek's extensive list of clients goes far and wide. From brides and models to your favorite celebs and social media stars, Shadi tailors her glam to match every client's unique visage. She first started honing her craft in Vancouver, Canada, and is now based in Los Angeles, one of the world's largest makeup hubs. Shadi often lends her expertise to publications such as WhoWhatWear, Bustle, Byrdie, Popsugar, and more. 

Natalie Dresher makeup artist
Natalie Dresher

Natalie Dresher is a highly sought-after makeup artist based in Miami and NYC, with over 10 years of experience in makeup artistry. Her impressive client roster includes notable names such as Remi Bader, Serena Kerrigan, Dylan Mulvaney, Jess Vestal, Gia Guidice, and more.Natalie's expertise has been recognized by leading makeup brands where she has served as the lead artist for influencer and editor-focused events and activations. In addition to her work with influencers and celebrities, Natalie has showcased her talent backstage at NYFW and Miami Swim Week for prestigious high-fashion brands.

TOPICS
Nykia Spradley
Contributing Beauty Writer

Nykia Spradley is a lifestyle journalist with over a decade of experience shaping editorial and e-commerce strategies for leading lifestyle media brands. Having held senior roles at SeventeenELLEAllure, and Essence, Nykia has built a reputation as a trusted voice in the shopping, beauty, style, and home spaces. You can find her work on Harper’s BazaarEsquireSeventeenELLEGlamourThe Strategist, and more. Nykia has tested everything from eye cream to mattresses and will always keep it real about what's worth your money before you add to cart.

With contributions from
Read more
samantha holender testing tubing mascara
12 Best Tubing Mascaras for Longer Lashes and Easy Removal, Reviewed by Beauty Experts
the best drugstore eyeshadows
The 15 Best Drugstore Eyeshadows for a High Impact Look, Tested by Editors
drugstore blush
The 13 Best Drugstore Blushes Offer Luxury Pigment on a Budget, Tested by Editors
models wearing drugstore moisturizer
The 11 Best Drugstore Moisturizers, According to Editors and Dermatologists
drugstore bronzers
The 13 Best Drugstore Bronzers to Fake a Tahiti-Level Glow, Tested by Editors
Testers test the best waterline eyeliners from Urban Decay and Maybelline and share their real-life reviews with Marie Claire
The 11 Best Eyeliners for Waterline, According to Beauty Experts
Latest in Makeup
makeup - pamela anderson
The Prettiest Beauty Looks Modeled By Celebrities Over 50
makeup - christy turlington
'90s Makeup Trends to Take Into 2025
70s makeup -  Lisa Taylor
'70s Makeup Trends That Surprisingly Hold Up Today
makeup - ali macgraw
The Best '60s Makeup Trends to Try
Editors Test SHEGLAM Skin Magnet Foundation
Yes, You Should Wear Foundation This Summer
Revolution Beauty Bronzing Drops
These $12 Bronzing Drops Are Elite
Latest in Buying-guide
meghan markle beauty routine
Meghan Markle Just Dropped Her Beauty Routine—These 8 Products Are Beauty-Editor Approved
Nikki Ogunnaike wearing a black button down shirt
4 Easy Spring Outfits That Always Get Compliments
Product collages
From Cream Blush to Pretty Linen Pieces, Here's What Should Be on Your Spring Wish List
the 2025 sunglasses trends at Chanel, Fendi, Gucci, Prada, Sportmax, Stella McCartney, Saint Laurent Spring 2025 runway shows
2025’s Sunglasses Trends Are Not for the Faint of Heart
spring 2025 shoe color trends on the runways of Chanel, Ferragamo, Rabanne, and Prada
Spring 2025's Candy-Coated Shoe Color Trends Prove Neutrals Are Overrated
women wearing white heels
Black Pumps Are Out—Everyone Is All-In on White Heels