In the last couple of years, my glosses and lipsticks have been left mostly untouched; the typical pops of color I gravitate towards are rendered invisible by masks. But it's left room for more makeup experimentation on the rest of my face: bright glitter, razor-sharp eyeliner, pigmented blush, and most of all, vibrant cream eyeshadows.
When should I use cream eyeshadow?
While powder shadow (opens in new tab) is a classic, I find that cream shadows are the formulas I've been clinging to in these trying times. And by trying times, I mean 95 degree days when the rest of my face is melting Raiders of the Last Ark-style. Cream shadows become my go-to for more than one reason: They blend like warm butter when I'm in the mood to mix and match different shades; lay comfortably on my lids like I've got nothing on; and stay put when I know I've got a long night devoid of touch-ups ahead of me.
How do I choose a cream eyeshadow?
Every month, there are brand new cream eyeshadow innovations, with each new product—from natural and organic formulas to exciting palettes—more intriguing than the last. While on the hunt for a cream shadow, don't just look for pigment and shine (though those are important!); look for formulas that go on smoothly and will last and last until you take makeup remover to it.
Since I've racked up quite the collection, I've gotten the chance to narrow down the absolute best of the best when it comes to cream formulas. From slick metallics to finely-ground glitters to translucent tints, here are the absolute best cream shadows to add to your cart.
Charlotte Tilbury Eyes to Mesmerize Cream Eyeshadow
Looking to up the drama? These cream shadows from legendary British brand Charlotte Tilbury don't skimp when it comes to shine and glitter. The shades are gorgeous on every skin tone, and are a great one-step product for immediate glam.
rms beauty Eyelights Cream Eyeshadow
Make your eyes look instantly more alive with a swipe of this shimmery shadow from cult-favorite clean makeup brand rms beauty. But these don't just look pretty: they're also formulated with natural peptide quinoa extract, a plant source that firms and smooths the eye area.
Revlon Colorstay Creme Eye Shadow
For a beauty novice, there is no way to apply this product incorrectly. A quick wash of color adds dimension and gorgeous color to the lids. It's the easiest product to use, and won't budge all day long.
Smashbox Always On Cream Shadow
If you need your eyeshadows to look the same at night as they did when you first applied them in the morning, this option from Smashbox is for you. It promises to be fade- and crease-resistant for up to 24 hours.
TOM FORD Cream Color for Eyes
You know that universally flattering golden hour light we chase when we're trying to 'get the shot'? This formula is that creamy filter, concentrated. The whipped mousse adds an illuminating pop to any eye shape.
Jones Road Sparkle Wash
Bobbi Brown is back with Jones Road, a minimal makeup brand that loves a little shimmer. This lightweight shadow from the line coats your entire lid in pretty, airy wash of color and glitter that still looks elevated.
Thrive Causemetics Infinity Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick
This creamy waterproof formula is a dream to apply. Wear it in a sharp line with one swipe (and keep the tip sharp thanks to the built-in sharpener) or blur it out with the handy smudge brush on the back.
Exa Beauty The Foils
Each of the four, buildable shades in this range of shadows is a masterclass in makeup that's both wearable and fun. You can layer them or wear them alone for a mix of metallic hues, and they can also be used on the face!
Alleyoop 11th Hour Cream Eyeshadow Sticks
This shadow stick goes on like a cream and sets into a powder that lasts for up to 11 hours—hence the very cute name. Perfect for throwing in your makeup bag for on-the-go application.
Trinny London Eye2Eye Shadows
These cream eyeshadows from Trinny London are available in 14 eye-enhancing shades, ranging from the palest shimmery champagne hue to a matte charcoal—and just about every option in between. Perfect for a one-product smoky eye look that won't budge.
Maybelline New York Eyestudio ColorTattoo Metal
These cream shadows from Maybelline are made to last 24 hours, and they live up to that test. Swipe on a color in the morning, and watch how they last till dinnertime.
Stila Glitter & Glow Liquid Eye Shadow
The formula is an editor favorite for a reason. The handy applicator allows for precise strokes, and the creamy liquid dries down after just a few seconds. And don't worry if you don't have time to touch your look up later—the formula is practically crease-proof.
about-face Matte Fluid Eye Paint
The brainchild of musician Halsey, these liquid shadows come in a range of cool-girl colors that won't budge an inch all day. They're easy to blend, and also make great eye primers if you want to layer on addition shadows on top.
Chanel Longwear Cream Eyeshadow
Want a little glamour in your life? These Chanel shadows are creamy and rich, and come in a range of colors for every mood. Not only is the packaging stunning, but they look stunning on the eyes and will definitely wow everyone you see.
ILIA Liquid Powder Chromatic Eye Tint
If you want the ease of a cream or liquid shadow but the smoothness of a powder, this product is calling your name. It's so easy to swipe on and blend out, and won't move even through sweat and humidity.
14 Wunder2 Super Stay Stick Eyeshadow
A smokey eye might sound like a project, but a swipe of this pencil along the lash lines creates a diffused, sultry gaze that won't turn crunchy as the hours pass.
NUDESTIX Magnetic Eye Color
A chubby pencil makes throwing on a full-on eye look as easy as signing your name. They glide on like butter, and you can smudge them out for a more smokey gaze. But once they're set, they're on for the night—no budging.
Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint
This sheer option screams "editorial." One thin layer adds a semi-translucent tint to the lids for some cool-girl edge.
-
Justice Clarence Thomas: LGBTQ+ Rights and Contraception Are Next"We should reconsider all of the Court's substantive due process precedents..."
-
Roe Is Gone. But We Have to Keep Fighting.
Democracy always offers a path forward even when we feel thrust into the past.
-
10 Abortion Rights Organizations Accepting Donations to Support Their Fight
'Roe' is no longer the law of the land, but these organizations won't stop fighting.
-
The 15 Best Blushes for Every Skin Tone and Season
Powders, liquids, and creams for every preference.
-
What Is Brow Lamination? Eyebrow Experts Weigh In
Brow lamination = like a perm, but for your eyebrows.
-
Hair Toner 101: Colorists Explain What Hair Toning Is and Why It Works
"Anyone with color treated hair should be using toners."
-
The 33 Best Shampoos and Conditioners, According to Marie Claire Editors
Curly hair, fine hair, textured hair—we've got you covered.
-
35 Lob Haircuts to Add to Your Mood Board in 2022
A tribute to the long bob, a.k.a. the cut that works on everyone.
-
The 12 Best Skin Extractor Tools in 2022
Blackheads, be gone.
-
19 Safe At-Home Keratin Treatments for Frizz-Free Hair
Shiny, silky, satiny.
-
The 13 Best Whitening Toothpastes That Work
Say goodbye to yellow stains.
