Not Even Wonder Woman Can Save 'Justice League' from Itself
The movie isn't insidious. It's just dumb.
The most entertaining scene in Justice League has absolutely no bearing on the rest of the plot: Wonder Woman detonates the bomb of some random terrorists by hurling it into the sky. Then, she methodically deflects every single bullet from a machine gun using her cuffs. It's rousing and fun in a way the rest of the movie absolutely is not.
Wonder Woman's release over the summer left me hankering for more from Diana Prince and her Amazon sisters. Hell, I even bought a branded "Daughters of Themyscira" jacket to show just how jazzed I was. But Patty Jenkins' movie seems to exist in a magical universe divorced from the aggressively bro-y and lethargic franchise known as the DC Extended Universe, so I went into Justice League with my expectations in check. Turns out, I was right to do so.
Is the movie as offensively terrible as, say, Suicide Squad? No. Nothing could ever be. Honestly, Justice League's main problem is that it's boring, and fails to convince me why I should care that "the fish man" is finally fighting alongside "the fast kid" and "the rich jerk in a bat costume" beyond the fact that they are all famous cultural properties. It's dramatically inert, peppered with lame quips that attempt to stand in for a genuine sense of humor, and—if you look closely—you can see just how important Jenkins' eye was now that it's gone. Good thing it will be back sooner than expected.
Justice League—directed by Man of Steel and Batman v Superman's Zack Snyder with an assist from Joss Whedon—is largely driven by endless exposition which dully lays out why/how the heroes are going to defeat the latest bad guy. The dude in question is Steppenwolf, and his thing is basically just that he's super evil. Ask me to explain anything else about him and I wouldn't be able to based on the screenplay alone. Like, uhhhhh, he also has these parademon creatures that follow him around looking like the Wizard of Oz monkeys gone terribly wrong? He needs to collect three boxes to achieve power? He's constructed via some painfully obvious CGI work?
Bruce Wayne (a grumbly Ben Affleck whose terrible press is hard to forget during the movie) and eventually Diana (the wonderful Gal Gadot) are clued into the threat and must recruit the hard-drinking Aquaman, the skittish Flash, and the brooding Cyborg. It takes some time—AKA an endless amount of time, AKA a little under two hours—but they eventually unite. And, hey, Superman's there too! How he survived that Batman v Superman death scene would constitute a spoiler, but never-fear, he's back, as is Henry Cavill's chest hair! And if you're distracted by how strange the actor's face looks, that's because the production had to edit out a mustache he had grown before reshoots using some technical wizardry. That sloppy edit is basically a metaphor for this movie.
So, what about Wonder Woman—does she manage to save Justice League from itself? The film is seemingly aware that Diana's the emotional lynchpin of the group, but doesn't know what to do with that. It can't figure out whether the other members should treat her as a maternal figure or a sex object, so it ends up doing both. "Children! I work with children," she jokingly exclaims during the climactic conflict. Meanwhile, the Flash momentarily freaks out after landing on top of her during a different battle, because, whoa, boobs; and the boorish Aquaman can't help but remark about how hot she is. Oh, and then there's Batman, who we're possibly (???) supposed to think is a viable love interest despite the fact that Affleck and Gadot have no demonstrable chemistry.
Example: A pivotal scene revolves around Diana making a reasonable argument about a dangerous mission, and Batman subsequently starts negging her about the death of Chris Pine's Steve Trevor. Cute? No. Mansplain-y? Yes.
Stay In The Know
Get exclusive access to fashion and beauty trends, hot-off-the-press celebrity news, and more.
There were other little indignities against Wonder Woman that I picked up on, too: The shot that lingers slightly too long on Diana's butt clad in leather pants; the insanely low cut shirt she wears which I can't imagine a female designer choosing. There has already been noise about the fact that some of the Amazons' costumes appear to have gotten skimpier between the two movies. The change is noticeable if you're attune to it, but what's even more enraging is that the warriors' primary purpose in Justice League is to brutally lose a skirmish to Steppenwolf. Oh, and if you're looking forward to the water-logged debut of Amber Heard's Mera, she's there for basically the same reason.
But for all of that, it's hard to read Justice League as an insidious movie. It's just sort of a dumb one—marred by a dysfunctional cinematic universe, and actors who are in the midst of publicity crises. Skip it, or see it for Wonder Woman's scenes and sleep through the rest.
RELATED STORIES
Esther Zuckerman is a freelance entertainment journalist and critic. Her work appears in the New York Times, GQ, Bloomberg, the Wall Street Journal, the Los Angeles Times, Indiewire, and Time among others. She is the author of three previous books: A Field Guide to Internet Boyfriends: Meme-Worthy Crushes from A to Z (2021), Beyond the Best Dressed: Cultural History of the Most Glamorous, Radical, and Scandalous Oscar Fashion Hardcover (2022), and Falling in Love at the Movies: Rom-Coms from the Screwball Era to Today (2024).
-
Sabrina Carpenter's Micro Shorts Are a Slice of Fashion History
She was brave to trot it out at the height of winter.
By Kelsey Stiegman Published
-
Tom Parker Bowles Says Stepfather King Charles Could be "Fantastic" at Another Job if He Wasn't Monarch
Just imagine.
By Kristin Contino Published
-
Cartier Celebrates 100 Years of Trinity With a Miami Pop-Up
A look inside the Art Basel event.
By Michaela Bushkin Published
-
The Best Inspirational Movies of All Time
You may want to keep a tissue box nearby.
By Katherine J. Igoe Published
-
Women Make Up One-Third of the Best Director Nominees at the 2025 Golden Globes
Congratulations are in order for Coralie Fargeat and Payal Kapadia!
By Sadie Bell Published
-
Even After 20 Years, We Can’t Stop Thinking About Natalie Portman’s Pink Wig in 'Closer'
Christine Blundell, the star’s hair and makeup artist on the project, reflects on the bubblegum bob and its legacy as the film celebrates its 20th anniversary.
By Sadie Bell Published
-
The 27 Best Biopics About Musicians of All Time
We're still stunned by these performances—many of which took home Oscars.
By Nicole Briese Published
-
Part of 'Wicked’s Magic? Its Cinematographer, Alice Brooks
The ‘Wicked’ director of photography had an extensive process for creating an Oz like movie audiences have never seen before.
By Esther Zuckerman Published
-
Is Hope Springs, New York Real? What to Know About the 'Hot Frosty' Filming Locations
Here's everything we know about the winter wonderland the rom-com was shot in.
By Quinci LeGardye Published
-
The Best Movies to Watch If You're Getting Into Old Hollywood Musicals for the First Time
Cinephiles and theater kids would agree that these Old Hollywood films are iconic.
By Katherine J. Igoe Published
-
The Best Movies About Female Friendship
From outrageous comedies to empowering dramas.
By Katherine J. Igoe Published