The Item I Wear to Death: My Black Lace-Up Sandals
A love story that will withstand time.

In our biweekly series, our editors will be sharing "the one item they wear to death," whether it be a basic white tee or a super-trendy jumpsuit. Prepare yourself (and your credit card) for some guilt-free shopping.
Two years ago, I fell in love with a pair of black, lace-up sandals—the kind of love that withstands time. (In the most literal sense, since these shoes have been by my side for 730 days and counting.) The Vagabond sandals are an integral part of my life, taking me from the city to the beach and from work to class.
I knew right away this was not going to be a fleeting love—they looked like they'd go with everything (and they do, as evidenced by my photos, ahead). I tromped around with one sandal on my left foot and my old white sneaker on my right. I looked in the mirror, I wiggled my toes, I fell deeper in love.
They are sturdy enough to delay death itself: The soles are made of extra grippy rubber; the thick laces that wrap around my ankles don't slide down. The shoe’s soft, worn-in leather (definitely fake, but still soft) keeps me from getting blisters. I have seriously walked miles in them. Those miles we’ve spent together have only made us closer, while, in other shoes, I finish long walks in a hate-filled cloud.
These qualities make them the perfect city shoe. I strolled over to Mud Coffee in the East Village in my black sandals:
I made them work for my Marie Claire internship with white jeans, a tee, and a black cardigan. The chunky yet delicate sandals added an interesting detail to the otherwise simple outfit.
The sandals transition easily into "going out" shoes at night. I wore them, here, with lightly washed jeans, a lingerie-style cami, and a long blazer to a bar in Brooklyn.
Although Vagabond, tragically, doesn't carry these particular sandals online anymore, I found a similar pair at Madewell. May you become as enchanted with your pair of black sandals as I am with mine.
Madewell boardwalk lace-up sandal, $60 SHOP IT
MORE ITEMS WE LOVE
Stay In The Know
Get exclusive access to fashion and beauty trends, hot-off-the-press celebrity news, and more.
Zoe is a contributing writer at MarieClaire.com; she covers celebrity and news. She loves sneakers and nicely organized bookshelves.
-
Jennifer Lopez Dips Her Fingers Into a Rising Manicure Trend
It's the perfect shade for solo V-Day plans.
By Hanna Lustig Published
-
Prince Charles Sent Princess Diana an Unexpectedly Touching Letter Before Their Wedding
The late royal shared the details of his intimate card and personalized gift.
By Kristin Contino Published
-
I'm Copying Issa Rae's View on Gray Hair Immediately
Her approach to aging is such a breath of fresh air.
By Ariel Baker Published
-
I’m Copying These Street Style Outfits I Spotted at New York Fashion Week
They're low-effort and high-impact.
By Lauren Tappan Published
-
Here’s What Marie Claire Editors Are Buying for Valentine's Day
From cherry red heels to sweet-smelling candles, we're oh-so in love with these products.
By The Editors at Marie Claire Published
-
Hailey Bieber Is the Quintessential Rich Mom Styling a Fur Coat, Massive Designer Bag, and Luxury Stroller
The Rhode Beauty founder keeps expanding her collection of mom-friendly designer bags.
By Amy Mackelden Published
-
Spring 2025's Shoe Trends Are All About Following Your Instincts
There's no formula. Instead, find the footwear that speaks to you.
By Emma Childs Published
-
A Classic White T-Shirt Is the Best Winter Styling Piece
This basic is the secret ingredient to creating the perfect outfit.
By Lauren Tappan Published
-
Jennifer Lopez’s Masterclass in Making Every Outfit Look Like a Billion Dollars
The secret to J.Lo’s impossibly glam style? It’s not just the Birkins—it’s the strategy. Here’s how she makes every single piece exude pure luxury.
By Lauren Tappan Published
-
Spring 2025 Trends I'm Already Shopping On-Sale From COS, Mango, and Reformation
Snag these sought-after styles before anyone else (and for less).
By Lauren Tappan Published
-
The Fashion Trends That Will Shape 2025
No crystal ball needed—our style experts have a clear vision of what's to come.
By Emma Childs Last updated