Marie Claire
  • Celebrity
  • Fashion
  • Beauty
  • Culture
  • Power
  • Nice Talk
  • Style at Large
  • More
    • Politics
    • Career & Money
    • Health & Fitness
    • Power Play
    • Travel
    • Promo Codes
    • Food & Cocktails
    • About Us
    • Subscribe
    • Sex & Love
  • Newsletter SIGN UP TO OUR NEWSLETTER
  • Marie Claire
    Marie Claire Newsletter

    The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.


    By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

    You are now subscribed

    Your newsletter sign-up was successful


    Want to add more newsletters?

    Marie Claire Daily

    Delivered daily

    Marie Claire Daily

    Get exclusive access to fashion and beauty trends, hot-off-the-press celebrity news, and more.

    Marie Claire Self Checkout

    Sent weekly on Saturday

    Marie Claire Self Checkout

    Exclusive access to expert shopping and styling advice from Nikki Ogunnaike, Marie Claire's editor-in-chief.

    Maire Claire Face Forward

    Once a week

    Maire Claire Face Forward

    Insider tips and recommendations for skin, hair, makeup, nails and more from Hannah Baxter, Marie Claire's beauty director.

    Livingetc

    Once a week

    Livingetc

    Your shortcut to the now and the next in contemporary home decoration, from designing a fashion-forward kitchen to decoding color schemes, and the latest interiors trends.

    Homes & Gardens

    Delivered Daily

    Homes & Gardens

    The ultimate interior design resource from the world's leading experts - discover inspiring decorating ideas, color scheming know-how, garden inspiration and shopping expertise.


    An account already exists for this email address, please log in.
    Trending
    • Early Black Friday
    • Sofia Franklyn
    • Plastic Surgery Week
    • Thanksgiving Outfits
    • 'The Body'
    • Deer Print
    1. Sex love

    He Read My Diary!

    When a writer's boyfriend found her secret tally of pros and cons about their relationship, she was forced to confront her true feelings.

    By Amy Pengra
    Published 23 January 2013 In News

    When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

    expert sex tips
    (Image credit: Archives)
    • Facebook
    • X
    • Pinterest
    Share this article
    Join the conversation
    Follow us
    Add us as a preferred source on Google
    Subscribe to our newsletter

    "I found the list, Amy," said Neil, my boyfriend, from the doorway of the bathroom, watching me step out of the tub.

    At first, I didn't know what he meant, but as I stood there naked, staring at his crestfallen face, it hit me: The List. Months ago, while trying to decide if I wanted to stay with Neil, I'd begun writing down the pros and cons of our relationship on a piece of paper. Obviously, I didn't want him to see the list, so I'd stuffed it between old towels in the linen closet. My head buzzed. How did he find it? And where were my clothes?!

    "That was ages ago," I stammered, my heart racing. "And hey ... did you read all the pros?"

    Latest Videos FromMarie Claire
    Watch full video here:

    "I read enough," he said, dropping the evidence on the floor and turning to leave.

    A little more than a year ago, I met Neil through friends. I was 37 and deep into dating exhaustion, having been mostly single for the previous four years. At first, I wasn't attracted to him. But he was kind and hilarious and brought me flowers. And we both wanted marriage and family.

    You may like
    • Megan Thee Stallion poses for Marie Claire Megan Thee Stallion Was "Constantly On Edge" Before Her Breakup With Klay Thompson
    • Harry Jowsey wears a tuxedo shirt while speaking with a woman in a wedding veil, in a still from the 'Let's Marry Harry' finale. We No Longer Think Marriage Is a "Prize." Why Do Netflix Dating Shows?
    • A collage of production photos from the play 'The Peterson Show,' with a portrait of playwright Janine Nabers at the center. I've Found Comedy Is Cheaper Than Therapy

    As time went by, though, I found him uptight and skittish. The fact that everyday hurdles could so easily unhinge him annoyed me. I couldn't decide if I wanted to break up. So after three months, I sat down to make a decision — and for me, the best way to do that was to start a list, something that's always made me feel organized and motivated to act. For example: Go to grad school? Pro: I'll be smarter. Con: I'll feel old fraternizing with Gen Yers.

    But this was the first time I'd kept a list on a relationship. At the time, it didn't seem like a red flag; I just wanted to clear my head. I began logically — pros included Neil's thoughtfulness, humor, and the fact that he loved my small boobs. Cons: his neediness, pessimism, and passive-aggressiveness. But then I started adding ridiculous cons whenever we had the slightest of tiffs: wears a belt with shorts, hates avocados.

    Marie Claire Newsletter

    The ultimate daily digest for women of power, purpose, and style.

    By submitting your information you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy and are aged 16 or over.

    When produce showed up on the list, I should have known that the relationship was over, but I was determined to make it work. So for every con I added — unstylish, moody — guilt urged me to bolster the pros: loves his family, good teeth. Now holding the list, I cringed. The final tally: 41 pluses and 39 minuses.

    That night I went to Neil's apartment to talk. He was stoic but hurt. "How would you feel reading everything you hate about yourself written down by the person who's supposed to love you?" he asked.

    "I'm sorry — I was just processing," I said. "You can make one about me."

    What to read next
    • Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans walk together outdoors, with Holmes looking toward the camera. Does Elizabeth Holmes’s Fiancé Want to Be Elizabeth Holmes?
    • a split image of food writer tarajia morrell reaching up to a high kitchen shelf and the cover of her memoir desire feeds the feast My Doctor Told Me to "Find a Man" If I Wanted to Be a Mom. Instead, I Took Up Gardening
    • a split image of a woman's silhouette dancing on a pole against an orange light and the cover of the book mona by azra liaqat khan I Was a Muslim Stripper in Post-9/11 New York

    "That won't help," he said. "But, look, this honesty could be good for us."

    I was shocked — he still wanted me. Me, whose imperfections could fill a database of cons. But maybe he was right. Maybe the airing of my concerns would help our relationship.

    The honesty that was supposed to bring us closer had clearly created resentment. When he lost his temper in traffic, Neil would glance at me and say with mocking sincerity, "Is this going on the list now?"

    One day a male acquaintance tagged Neil and me in a Facebook post, gushing that he hoped to find a love like ours. The portrayal of our "perfect love" forced me to confront the truth: I didn't love Neil. And I should have realized that when I was scribbling trivial things like "can't drive stick" on my list of gripes, which, in truth, was more about me than him. We stayed together for five more months, but I eventually broke up with him, and I learned something invaluable, too. I don't need a list to tell me what's in my heart.

    Amy Pengra
    Read more
    Elizabeth Holmes and Billy Evans walk together outdoors, with Holmes looking toward the camera.
    Movies Does Elizabeth Holmes’s Fiancé Want to Be Elizabeth Holmes? The documentary ‘You Can See Everything’ might be the most disturbing love story to come out of Silicon Valley.
    By Noor Ibrahim
    a split image of food writer tarajia morrell reaching up to a high kitchen shelf and the cover of her memoir desire feeds the feast
    Books My Doctor Told Me to "Find a Man" If I Wanted to Be a Mom. Instead, I Took Up Gardening "As I usually do in times of distress, I felt a pull toward nature," writes James Beard-winning author Tarajia Morrell.
    By Tarajia Morrell
     
     
    a split image of a woman's silhouette dancing on a pole against an orange light and the cover of the book mona by azra liaqat khan
    Books I Was a Muslim Stripper in Post-9/11 New York "Race, you see, wasn’t just assigned at the club; it was performed," writes Azra Liaqat Khan in her memoir 'Mona.'
    By Azra Liaqat Khan
    A photo of Nikki Ogunnaike with an inset photo of Sofia Franklyn and text reading Money. Power. Style. Nice Talk with Nikki Ogunnaike
    Culture Sofia Franklyn's Advice for Anyone Going Through a Friendship Breakup The podcaster's new memoir, 'Daddy Issues', details her split from friend and collaborator Alex Cooper.
    By Lia Beck
     
     
    Latest in Sex love
    Two women covered in blood (Gillian Anderson as Billy and Hannah Einbinder as Kris) stand closely together in a convenience store aisle, with their intertwined hands on a cart. A still from Jane Schoenbrun's 'Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma' (2026).
    Movies Everyone Has Thoughts About Gen Z and Sex. 'Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma' Gets It Right
    Princess Diana wears a shimmering blue mini dress and carries a matching blue silk clutch bag
    Royals How Diana Navigated Being a "Newly Divorced Princess"
     
     
    Queen Camilla wears off-white and pale green on her wedding day, including a white hat, to marry King Charles in 2005
    Royals Why Queen Camilla "Felt a Little Broken" on Her Wedding Day
    Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce are married at Madison Square Garden and a sign announces their nuptials outside
    Celebrity What Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce Said in Their Wedding Vows
     
     
    Latest in News
    Prince William clasping his hands and smiling
    Royals Prince William Reveals He and Princess Kate Have a “Big Year Next Year”
    King Charles wearing a tan coat and smirking
    Royals Grandpa King Charles Brought Home a "Positive Potato" for the Kids
     
     
    Prince William and Princess Kate walking the Earthshot Prize red carpet
    Royals Princess Kate Played a Secret Role in Developing the Earthshot Prize
    Zoë Kravitz was spotted in NYC wearing a pink button-down, a classic trench coat, New Balance sneakers, and a red scarf
    Celebrity Style Zoë Kravitz’s Cool-Girl Scarf Era Continues With a New Color Trend
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
     
    Marie Claire
    RSS
    • About us
    • Contact Future's experts
    • Contact us
    • Advertise Online
    • Newsletter
    • Terms and conditions
    • Privacy policy
    • Cookies policy
    • Careers
    Add as a preferred source on Google Add as a preferred source on Google

    Marie Claire is part of Future US Inc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Visit our corporate site.

    © Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, New York, NY 10036.