All of Our Lingering Questions After Parts 1 & 2 of the 'Summer House' Season 10 Reunion

Outside of 2023's Vanderpump Rules "Scandoval" bombshell, there had never been a reality TV reunion as anticipated as the three-parter for Summer House season 10. And with all the off-camera drama and revelations this year surrounding "Scamanda," it's understandable that fans couldn't wait to hear directly from the cast. Amanda Batula and West Wilson were in attendance and had to face their respective exes and former friends, Kyle Cooke and Ciara Miller, for the first time on camera since the earth-shattering news about their coupling broke on March 31, 2026.

The reunion itself has had its own share of drama beyond the cast's interpersonal relationships; a day after the April 23 recording, audio from the Bravo special was leaked by an unnamed member of production. Host Andy Cohen spoke out about the leak, calling it “disgusting and illegal for someone to leak or distribute this.”

Now, finally, the first two parts of the season's 3-part finale have aired, and the two hours gave us many of the answers we've been craving as it pertains to Amanda and West's relationship as well as Amanda and Kyle's breakup. But some things were still left unanswered, and will hopefully be addressed when part 3 airs on Tuesday, June 9. In the meantime, here are the storylines and questions we still have for the reality show's remaining reunion.

Why did West want to commit to Amanda?

When West is asked about his on-again-off-again relationship with Ciara, his most sturdy defense is that he wasn't looking for a relationship. The reunion plays back a few clips from season 10 in which West reiterates to different parties that he's not trying to be anyone's boyfriend right now, despite "having a crush" on Ciara. Part 2 of the reunion complicates this further when Ciara calls West's ex Meija during the cast's lunch break, who confirms that she and West were exclusive last summer during filming, but that he didn't want to go public with their relationship because he was allegedly afraid that he'd get kicked off the show.

His fear of a public relationship goes out the window in March 2026 when he and Amanda confirmed their relationship. While the Instagram statement didn't use the words "boyfriend" or "girlfriend," it did indicate a level of seriousness that runs counter to his previous statements and actions. Neither Andy nor anyone in the cast poked holes in this excuse in part 1 of the reunion, and in part 2, Amanda says that they've talked privately about what their entanglement would look and feel like. But we still haven't heard directly from West about how he's defining the relationship. It feels like the type of admission that could heal some wounds for Ciara—so here's hoping we get a better look inside West's mind in part 3.

Why did Amanda and West lie—and did they know how much they were risking?

Parts 1 and 2 of the reunion dive into some of the juicy details of their courtship, but we still don't have a concrete answer as to why they would do something so seismic to their friends (and, honestly, to us).

Amanda and West also acknowledge that they lied to everyone about their budding romance (Ciara does an incredible live reading of the text messages between her and Amanda from early March), which suggests they knew what they were doing was wrong. In part 2, Amanda doubles down on her defense that she had to follow her strong feelings for West. But there's much more to unpack about how they came to the decision to pursue each other, what they expected the fallout to be, and how they plan to make amends.

What is the exact timeline of Amanda and West's emotional relationship?

Amanda and West gave us some important details during part 1: West made the first move, they shared their first kiss at the end of February, and didn't sleep together until April, after the statement was released. But after the news about their coupling broke to the public, many fans began picking up on Amanda and West's physical proximity and "friendly" touching in the back half of season 10, raising the question of when each of them began having feelings for the other and whether it dated back to last summer.

Amidst all of this, Ciara also publicly revealed on the reunion that she and West had a few sleepovers in the fall and that West was dating someone else in January. January is when he allegedly first admitted his feelings to Amanda and when Ciara first realized something might be up when she clocked Amanda's location at West's apartment.

Part 2 didn't reveal much more about West and Amanda's timeline, but it did give us some more background on her breakup with Kyle. Kyle confirms that he didn't realize they were breaking up until the day the statement was drafted and released (he claims he barely even had time to tell his family), while Amanda says she knew she was done with the marriage on New Year's Day, when she found out that Kyle wound up in a Hoboken hotel after a night of DJing.

With their separation and impending divorce in the mix, and we might need to pull out a calendar and a ball of yarn to unpack the exact timeline and pinpoint the overlaps.

Does Amanda realize how much she hurt Ciara?

The reason that this scandal became the only thing the internet could talk about is that it violated the golden rule of girl code: don't date your friend's ex. After two parts, Amanda continues to be defensive and hasn't acknowledged how hurtful her actions were—even as Ciara continuously points out the juxtaposition of how good of a friend she was to Amanda.

As Marie Claire Fashion Features Writer Emma Childs said in our live Part 1 coverage, "I'm hoping Andy asks Amanda to reflect on how duplicitous she’s been to her so-called ‘best friend.’" So far, the jury is still out and the clock is ticking.

Will Amanda and West apologize to Ciara and Kyle (and the rest of the housemates)?

Near the beginning of the first hour, Amanda tells Andy that she's "prepared to own up to what I’ve done, take accountability, apologize—especially to Ciara and Kyle—and just hopefully be able to explain to everyone’s face what went on and where I’m coming from." But after two full hours, we still haven't heard the words "I'm sorry" come out of either of their mouths (nor have we gotten closer to understanding where she's coming from). With only one hour left, we're getting skeptical as to whether Ciara and Kyle will get an apology at all.

Are KJ and Dara still together?

We got major relationship updates from a few members of the cast: Ben Waddell leveled up his relationship with Sabrina Belle when he took her to Australia to meet his family, Mia Calabrese broke up with her boyfriend Scott Robert Williams and is in her single era, and Bailey Taylor and Carl Radke are keeping the door open.

The first part of the reunion didn't address KJ Dillard's relationship with Dara Levitan, which turned official during the filming of season 10. Instead, KJ shared a deeply personal update about his mental health, revealing that he was hospitalized due to self-harm in the fall and was diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. Thankfully, he says he's doing well and focusing on himself with the support of Ciara and Mia.

Dara joins the cast onstage in part 2, giving KJ a kiss while confirming their relationship, calling it the "strongest relationship" that she's had. But fans are wondering if the pair are still together after noticing that they no longer follow each other on Instagram and she didn't attend Carl's reunion watch party at Soft Bar. (After all, the reunion was filmed over a month ago.) To complicate things even further, Dara and KJ posed together at Ciara's DSW partnership party last week, so until they release a public statement, it's unclear where they stand.

What's going on with Kyle's DJ career, his drink company Loverboy, and Carl's non-alcoholic venture Soft Bar?

They're far from the juiciest parts of the season, but we'll likely still get some business update from both Kyle and Carl—especially because Kyle's DJ career was a driving force in his separation from Amanda. Kyle's lack of investment in Soft Bar also created some tension between him and Carl, though they mostly squashed that beef at the end of season 10.

Part 2 touched on the success of Soft Bar, which had been open for 10 months at the time of the recording with some admitted ups and downs, but so far we haven't checked in on Kyle's businesses at all. That's understandable, given there's much more heated discussions around him and his personal relationships to be had, but it would be nice to get a check-in on where Kyle's ventures stand today.

Who will return for 'Summer House' season 11?

Bravo officially announced that Summer House will return for season 11 next year, but there's no confirmation regarding which cast members will return. There's almost no chance that Ciara, Amanda, West, and Kyle will share another room, let alone a whole summer house, so we're hotly anticipating what cast shakeups are in store for the next season.