It was a moment tailor-made for the internet. When Melania Trump seemingly batted away her husband's outstretched hand (opens in new tab) as they arrived in Israel last week, the swat was gleefully meme-ified—the first lady's hand flick made into a gif, played in slow-motion, and covered by news outlets worldwide. The schadenfreudic fever was heightened a few days later when Melania appeared to recoil from Trump's touch a second time (opens in new tab) in Rome.
It's an understandable response on our part; there's something enjoyable about watching a man who thinks he can grab women's genitals with impunity being rejected by his wife. And for those of us who find it hard to fathom how any woman could stand to be in the same room as Trump—let alone his bed—it's satisfying to believe that Melania might hate him just as much as we do.
But projecting our disgust with Trump onto the first lady is a temporary cathartic fix at best. At worst, it's a willing disregard for how Trump's rise to the presidency has been powered by women: his wife, his daughter, and the 53 percent of white women who voted for him.
The idea of universal female disdain for this president is a nice fantasy, but if we're going to effectively fight back against Trump, we can't afford to empathize with his enablers.
For all the #FreeMelania rhetoric, this is a woman who has consistently and actively supported Trump's misdeeds. In 2011, Melania appeared on Joy Behar's CNN show (opens in new tab) supporting her husband's racist birther campaign; during the election, she dismissed Trump's boasts about groping women as just "how some men talk." (opens in new tab) The soon-to-be first lady also suggested that the women who accused Trump of sexual assault were lying (opens in new tab) or part of an organized effort by Democrats to malign her husband.
Along with her step-daughter Ivanka Trump—who gives her father full-throated support, going so far as to call him a feminist (opens in new tab)—Melania provides the president with a polished cover both for his misogyny and his general ineptitude.
Take conservative writer Kathleen Parker's piece last week in The Washington Post (opens in new tab), more love letter than column. When Trump visited Saudi Arabia, Parker wrote that Melania and Ivanka "stood as beacons of light in a part of the world that remains cloaked in the darkness...preternaturally beautiful, they seemed to glide as apparitions." Parker lauds the women for demonstrating to the world "that despite our coarse, ham-fisted president, we have not completely forsaken class." (Parker admits they did all this "wordlessly," because apparently the best accomplishment a woman can hope for is to be beautiful and silent.)
This depiction of Ivanka and Melania as civilizing forces on Trump—a ridiculous assertion disproven over (opens in new tab) and again (opens in new tab)—is in part why so many women voted for a raving misogynist in the first place. Buzzfeed's Anne Helen Petersen called them the "Ivanka voters (opens in new tab)": "If Trump produced someone that classy, that's a testament to something," one woman told her. If Melania sees something in him, why can't we?
It's not a new tact for conservatives; they've long trotted out women to put a female-friendly veneer on their anti-woman policies: from Phyllis Schlafly telling Americans the Equal Rights Amendment was actually bad for women to Sarah Palin calling herself a feminist while the city she was mayor of charged women for their rape kits (opens in new tab). But conservative women aren't unwitting pawns, and Melania and Ivanka don't deserve an ounce of sympathy nor the benefit of the doubt. Not while so many are in danger of losing their rights—or even their lives. (opens in new tab)
I get it. Given the way Trump treats women publicly, it's not hard to make the leap that he might treat them badly in private as well. It's why images of the first lady looking sad go viral, or why there's so much focus on the ungentlemanly way Trump often walks ahead of his wife (opens in new tab). It's easier to root for a woman, to want her to "escape" a bad guy, than to admit she might be the bad guy.
There's nothing wrong with seeking levity in the news, given how horrific our politics are right now. And I will gladly admit that I played the video of Melania's hand slap more than once. But when the jokes are done, and we've logged off for the night, let's remember that it's not Melania who needs to be "freed." It's us.
Jessica Valenti is a contributing editor to MarieClaire.com—read her weekly column here (opens in new tab).
Jessica Valenti is a columnist and author of five books on feminism, politics, and culture. Her latest book, Sex Object: A Memoir, was a New York Times bestseller. Valenti is also editor of the ground-breaking anthology Yes Means Yes: Visions of Female Sexual Power and a World Without Rape and the founder of Feministing.com, which Columbia Journalism Review called “head and shoulders above almost any writing on women’s issues in mainstream media.” She has a Master’s degree in Women’s and Gender Studies and lives in Brooklyn with her husband and daughter.
Actor Rupert Everett Refutes Prince Harry’s Claims About Where Harry Lost His Virginity
“I’m just putting it out there that I know.”
By Rachel Burchfield
This Year’s Hottest Wine Club
The subscription service made by wine lovers, for wine lovers.
Found: Bracelets to Fall For
Get ready to mix, match, and stack.
By Brooke Knappenberger
Current Gun Control Policies Are Ableist
"Solutions" like active shooter drills and arming more people put the rights of gun owners above the rights of America's most vulnerable, including disabled people like myself.
By Heather Tomko
Sex Trafficking Victims Are Being Punished. A New Law Could Change That.
Victims of sexual abuse are quietly criminalized. Sara's Law protects kids that fight back.
By Dr. Devin J. Buckley and Erin Regan
Today, on Human Rights Day, the U.S. Must Abolish Child Marriage
In all but six states, American adults can marry people aged 17 and younger.
By Saryn Chorney
It’s Time to End Equal Pay Days and Pass the Equal Rights Amendment
The passage of the ERA is a chance for our country to prove it truly values women.
By Hala Ayala
One Year Later, We Must Remember George Floyd's Legacy
Virginia gubernatorial candidate Jennifer Carroll Foy has experienced America's two-tiered system firsthand. Here, what she believes is needed in the continuing fight for racial justice.
By Jennifer Carroll Foy
Yes, Caregiving Is Essential Infrastructure
President Biden’s American Families Plan is further proof that care is necessary for economic growth.
By Valerie Jarrett
Paid Leave for All Is Necessary for Our Country to Recover
Amanda Brown Lierman and Dawn Huckelbridge argue that passing a comprehensive paid leave plan is imperative to supporting women in the workplace—and America's economic future.
By Amanda Brown Lierman
Senator Hirono on Her Journey to the U.S. Senate and Having a "Heart of Fire"
At first glance, 'Heart of Fire' is a political memoir. At its core, it's an ode to a mother who changed her daughter's life.
By Rachel Epstein