The 11 Biggest Plot Holes in 'Game of Thrones'

Nope. Sorry. Not buying it.

Hair, Head, Nose, Mouth, Lip, Cheek, Eye, Hairstyle, Skin, Chin,
(Image credit: Archives)

Much as we love Game of Thrones, even a world populated by magicians, monsters, and dragons has to have some internal consistency. But it's left us scratching our heads (and turning to Google for answers) more than once.

So after an obsessive analysis and too many cups of coffee, we've picked out 11 times the show made no sense.

Statue, Outerwear, Temple, Art, Monument, Sculpture,

(Image credit: Archives)

Even just Westeros and Essos combined makes for a pretty big land mass, so how exactly do characters on GoT zip from one kingdom to another in such a short space of time?

Littlefinger alone traversed something close to 3,500 miles in just a few episodes, while Tyrion's trip from Winterfell to Meereen would equal upwards of 6,000 miles.

"The timelines of the various story threads don't necessarily match up all the time," producer Bryan Cogman has insisted (opens in new tab). "This is to avoid things like, say, Arya spending four episodes on a boat."

Hmm. Not convinced. We prefer our own theory that Varys has mastered the power of teleportation (opens in new tab).

See more

2. How did Arya survive her stabbing by the Waif?

Statue, Sculpture, Monument, Eye, Human, Art, Smile, Photography, Temple, Tourism,

(Image credit: Archives)

She's a tough cookie, no question, but for Arya to survive a knife being shoved into her guts—and twisted—by the Waif? And then to engage in an epic parkour chase through the streets of Braavos? And all it took to tend her wounds was a little TLC from Lady Crane?

It took less to off the mighty Khal Drogo. Nope. Sorry. Not buying it.

3. Why didn't Jon Snow's resurrection require a blood sacrifice?

Barechested, Chest, Head, Chin, Muscle, Art, Human, Trunk, Neck, Sculpture,

(Image credit: Archives)

Stannis' demonic curses on his opponents—Robb Stark, Balon Greyjoy, and Joffrey Baratheon—required "King's blood" leeched from Gendry. Melisandre had to burn poor Princess Shireen just to stop it snowing.

But all it took to bring Jon Snow back from the dead was a quick sponge down and a haircut? What are the rules here?

4. Melisandre took off her necklace once before—and nothing happened

Beauty, Cg artwork, Photography, Black hair, Art model, Portrait, Long hair, Chest, Flesh, Fictional character,

(Image credit: Archives)

Slipping off her magic necklace at the close of last year's "The Red Woman (opens in new tab)" revealed Melisandre's true form—pale, wizened, and almost impossibly ancient.

But wait, didn't she take her necklace off once before, while taking a bath in season four's "Mockingbird (opens in new tab)?" With no ill effect? (Carice van Houten has, however, explained this one away as an "oops moment.")

5. How did the Sand Snakes teleport to King's Landing?


(Image credit: Archives)

The women of Dorne seized control in season six, executing both Doran Martell and his heir Prince Trystane.

Except...Trystane was on a boat moored at King's Landing. How exactly did the Sand Snakes make their way to the capital, board Jaime's ship, murder the prince and escape back to Dorne, totally undetected?

6. Why didn't Tywin figure out who Arya was?

Fashion, Human, Conversation, Interaction, Photography, Scene, Screenshot, Flash photography, Gesture, Performance,

(Image credit: Archives)

Tywin Lannister was a wily old sod, as cunning as he was cruel. So why, when Arya posed as a servant boy and fell into the King's service at Harrenhal, didn't he suspect who she was?

He knew that she was a girl from the off, but even when he learned that his new cupbearer was noble-born, from the North, and in hiding...He didn't figure her for Arya Stark? Nah.

7. How did Will survive his encounter with the White Walkers?

Human, Screenshot, Adaptation, Movie, Beard,

(Image credit: Archives)

We'll forgive you for not remembering Will, who appeared only in the GoT series premiere. A ranger of the Night's Watch, Will not only escaped a pack of Wights but somehow made it from the Wall to Winterfell—hundreds of miles—without food, water or any supplies.

Ned Stark didn't believe his story either and executed Will as a deserter. Can't say we blame him for being suspicious. We might accept that the White Walkers let him go because they wanted the living to know that the dead were coming—but if so, why?

8. Why didn't Tyrion seek revenge on Littlefinger?

Head, Cheek, Human, Portrait, Photography, Portrait photography, Screenshot,

(Image credit: Archives)

Cast your mind all the way back to season one. An assassin bearing a dagger made of Valyrian steel tried and failed to kill the crippled Bran Stark. Littlefinger did what he does best and lied, placing the blame at Tyrion's door.

Tyrion was freed after Bronn won a trial by combat on his behalf, but why has he never attempted to get even with Petyr Baelish since? We guess he's been kept pretty busy.

9. How did Khal Drogo melt that gold so fast?

Human, Screenshot, Event, Photography, Fictional character, Performance,

(Image credit: Archives)

Yes, it was super badass, but unless the rules of physics are entirely different in Westeros, Khal Drogo's method of murdering Viserys Targaryen makes zero sense.

The melting point of gold is nearly 2,000 degrees fahrenheit. The average cooking fire, at most, would reach approximately 700 degrees. Yet Drogo melts five gold medallions into a bucketful of molten liquid in a matter of seconds. Balderdash.

10. Do Euron's shipwrights have magical powers?

Vehicle, Boat, Watercraft, Sail, Sailboat, Caravel, Art,

(Image credit: Archives)

Opinions are divided over whether Euron Greyjoy brings a welcome dash of irreverence or an annoying splash of irrelevance, but there's no explaining his mighty fleet. Yara and Theon stole his best ships while he was revelling in inheriting the Driftwood Crown. Maybe they're really fast runners. Fine.

Euron told the Iron Islanders—all 20 or so who had assembled on the cliffs—to build him a fleet of 1,000 ships. And hey presto, by the next season it's done. And not just any ships—awesome ships that destroyed the (other) Greyjoy and Dornish combined forces.

In the 16th century—just for comparison—it took shipyards up to a year to build one ship. Just how many shipwrights does Euron have back on those poxy little islands? And where's he getting the wood from?

11. Where the hell is Gendry?

Recreation, Transport, Water, Watercraft, Boat, Outdoor recreation, Boating, Skiff, Lake, Boats and boating--Equipment and supplies,

(Image credit: Archives)

Still rowin'.

[mediaosvideo align="center" autoPlay="0" embedId="7d180b22-3e2c-4127-9501-534c7f2bd57c" mediaId="eb087d42-9ea9-4ba5-b43a-13a173f68793" size="large"][/mediaosvideo]

Follow Marie Claire on Facebook for the latest celeb news, beauty tips, fascinating reads, livestream video, and more.