

Three days have passed since the unprecedented Best Picture fiasco—which singlehandedly turned the 2017 Oscars from uneventful to infamous—and we're still piecing together exactly how La La Land was erroneously announced as Best Picture instead of the night's actual winner, Moonlight.
We know that presenter Warren Beatty was handed the wrong envelope backstage—the one meant for Best Lead Actress winner Emma Stone—and that accounting firm PricewaterhouseCoopers were to blame. But the details beyond that are still fuzzy, so much so that Beatty himself is calling on the Academy president to "publicly clarify what happened as soon as possible."
Now, Variety has released new photos from backstage that show how PricewaterhouseCooper' Brian Cullinan came to make his critical error. Let's walk down this road of clusterfuckery together, shall we?
11:53 p.m. ET
Beatty hugs Best Actor winner Casey Affleck backstage. Cullinan can be seen nearby, holding two red envelopes in his left hand, along with his cellphone. As Variety's story suggests, these two envelopes most likely contain the winners of the final two categories of the night: Best Actress and Best Picture.
Let's take a closer look:
One of these envelopes—notably, the wrong one—ended up in Beatty's hand.
A few minutes later...
Beatty watches the monitor backstage as the Best Actress award is presented. (Congrats, Emma Stone!) Cullinan is beside him.
12:05 a.m. ET
Cullinan tweets a now-deleted picture of Emma Stone backstage. Reports emerged after Sunday's debacle that he was asked not to tweet during the ceremony. So inevitably people think this was the moment he got distracted (you had one job, Brian!) and hey, we've all been there—just not on a stage this public.
12:12 a.m. ET
Dunaway announces that La La Land has won Best Picture. Below, she's pictured holding the wrong envelope—for Best Lead Actress, which Cullinan had handed Beatty backstage.
You know the rest. The La La Land producers made their way to the stage and were midway through their acceptance speeches when they were alerted to the error. Watch the WTF moment here:
A post shared by Marie Claire (@marieclairemag)
A photo posted by on
Three-and-a-half minutes after the incorrect announcement, Cullinan appears on stage, where his colleague Martha Ruiz hands him the correct envelope. Below, La La Land producer Fred Berger (the "We lost, by the way" guy) speaks at the microphone while Cullinan confers with Ruiz and production staff.
And there you have it. PwC already confirmed in a statement Monday that Cullinan was responsible for handing Beatty the wrong envelope, and that he "feels very, very terrible and horrible" about the mistake.
Here's Cullinan and Ruiz in happier times.
The next time you're having a bad day at work, spare a kind thought for Cullinan.
Follow Marie Claire on Facebook for the latest celeb news, beauty tips, fascinating reads, livestream video, and more.
Emma Dibdin is a freelance writer based in Los Angeles who writes about culture, mental health, and true crime. She loves owls, hates cilantro, and can find the queer subtext in literally anything.
-
Meghan Markle Shared a Poignant Message About Working Moms as She Calls for More Childcare Support
Archewell is supporting the "National Business Coalition for Child Care."
By Iris Goldsztajn
-
Kanye West Told Kim Kardashian She Was Dressed Like Marge Simpson and Her Career Was Over After the WSJ Innovator Awards
This is awful.
By Iris Goldsztajn
-
Kate Middleton Just Revealed Prince Louis' Favorite Superhero
A fine choice.
By Iris Goldsztajn
-
The 50 Best 2000s Movies
Juicy Couture tracksuit recommended, but not required.
By Bianca Rodriguez
-
90 Movies You Have to Watch at Least Once in Your Life
The essentials. (Netflix password not included.)
By Bianca Rodriguez
-
The 79 Best '90s Movies That Are Modern Classics
Truly the golden age of cinema.
By Kayleigh Roberts
-
The 50 Best Feel-Good Movies to Curl Up With
PJs, a glass of wine, and these films.
By Katherine J Igoe
-
The 51 Best Musical Movies to Get You Singing
All the dance numbers! All the show tunes!
By Amanda Mitchell
-
The 40 Best Psychological Thrillers of All Time
Not stressed enough already? Then watch these movies.
By Zoe Guy
-
The 14 Best Drama Movies of 2022 (So Far)
From acclaimed indie films to music biopics.
By Quinci LeGardye
-
The 9 Best Movies With Lesbian Characters on Netflix
From Oscar-nominated period films to easy-to-watch rom-coms, consider these required watching for LBGTQ+ and allied viewers alike.
By Melissa Kravitz Hoeffner