Most Coveted is a shopping series sharing our editors’ curation of the must-know items they can’t stop thinking about.
So, I may or may not be the "difficult person" mentioned in the headline. Since I spend most of the year indulging in my favorite products, when it's time for gift-giving season, my loved ones often come up blank. On the plus side, being labeled as "hard to shop for" has allowed me to become an excellent gift-giver, so trust me when I say that I know exactly what someone with selective taste would like. Here's a general rule of thumb: Good gifts don't need to be expensive, and not every luxury gift will impress. My gift to you is this collection of 35 fashion and beauty items for the picky people in your life. With handbags, sweaters, denim, sneakers, LED masks, and more, there's something for everyone on your list below.
Coach
Soft Empire Carryall Bag 48
The bag that reigned supreme all year long isn't going anywhere. The fashion person on your list would love this gem.
Gap
Collarless V-Neck Sweater Blazer (Was $148)
Ultra chic and under $200.
Old Navy
Wow High-Waisted Barrel Ankle Jeans (Was $45)
If they lived in barrel jeans this year, they won't mind another pair.
adidas
Taekwondo Mei Shoes
These have "bound to sell out" written all over them.
Pandora
Double Band Heart Ring
Have you seen a more perfect pinky ring?
Banana Republic
High-Rise Wide-Leg Hammered Satin Palazzo Pant
For the person who prefers satin pants over sweatpants.
Marciano by Guess
Metallic Oval Clutch (Was $150)
Truth be told, this clutch looks triple the price. Prepare for endless compliments.
Marciano by Guess
Suede Knee-High Stiletto Boot (Was $350)
The gift of main-character energy.
Therabody
SmartGoggles (Was $220)
The person who is working around the clock deserves lower stress levels, better sleep, and less headaches.
I'd happily unwrap a fresh pair of kicks.
Banana Republic
Distressed Leather Flight Jacket
I hate to be dramatic, but owning this jacket feels like a major style indicator.
Gap
Leather Gloves (Was $98)
Your most basic winter looks will feel much more elevated if these gloves are involved.
Banana Republic
Leather Essential Clog
The studded detail is sublime.
Nanoleaf Shop Global
6-In-1 Light Therapy Wand
Healthy, glowing skin and a cute device to have on your bathroom counter? Sounds like a great gift to me.
Gap
Recycled Sherpa & Vegan Leather-Trim Jacket (Was $268)
Replace someone's black puffer with this chic alternative.
Pandora
Infinite 14k Gold Lab-Grown Diamond Double Chain Collier Necklace
Old Navy
Snug Boatneck T-Shirt (Was $17)
No matter how large someone's white tee collection is, there's always room for a new one. This boatneck style is a bit more elegant.
Therabody
TheraFace Mask (Was $650)
Upgrade their nighttime routine with a new LED mask ritual.
Old Navy
Low-Rise Slouchy Straight Jeans (Was $50)
Under-$50 denim that they'll wear on repeat.
Marciano by Guess
Eco Astrid Asymmetric Draped Top (Was $140)
Trade their classic black turtleneck for this draped top.
Pandora
Triple Heart Hoop Earrings (Was $165)
The chicest three-in-one hoop earrings.
Old Navy
Cloudmotion Funnel Neck Top (Was $25)
Old Navy has incredible activewear. The Pilates lover in your life will adore this.
Old Navy
Extra-High Waisted PowerSoft Boundless 7/8 Pocket Leggings (Was $40)
Is there a such thing as too many leggings?
Old Navy
Low-Rise Slouchy Straight Jeans (Was $50)
Comfortable denim for the win.
Marciano by Guess
Aida Maxi Cable-Knit Sweater (Was $180)
This is the kind of gift you immediately put on after unwrapping it.
Aroma360
Paris Collection Room Spray (Was $60)
Homebodies, rise. This blend of sandalwood, cedar, florals, Tuscan leather, and amber is just for you.
Consider this an ode to the sneakerheads on your list.
Pandora
Pandora Moments Brown Braided Double Leather Bracelet (Was $80)
This is not your typical Pandora bracelet, but it's an unexpected gift that will have people swooning.
adidas
Grand Court Lo Shoes
Easy, everyday sneakers for the people on-the-go.
Remedy Science
Hand Remedy Advanced Hand & Cuticle Butter Cream
For the friend who has any and everything at the bottom of their Mary Poppins bag. This hand cream is a must.
adidas
SL 72 OG Shoes (Was $100)
This is my official petition to experiment with fun shoes in 2026.
Banana Republic
Featherweight Cashmere Turtleneck
Not your average turtleneck. Look at the contrast piping.
Aroma360
Iris 500ml Reed Diffuser (Was $170)
The scent is inspired by Diptyque's Baies. Need I say more?
Banana Republic
Lightweight Cashmere Low V-Neck Sweater
I can't get over the exaggerated deep V.
Aroma360
Midnight in Paris Single-Wick Candle (Was $50)
We all know at least one candle collector.