The 11 Best Bronzers for Fair Skin, Tested and Reviewed by Editors

No orange glow in sight.

models wearing bronzer with fair skin
(Image credit: Launchmetrics)

In college, I used to say bronzer was my desert-island beauty product—the one thing I'd always take with me. Today, I'd simply haul my entire makeup bag with me when I travel, but the point remains: I always have and always will love a great bronzer. But, not all bronzers are made equal, and it can be especially difficult to find the best bronzer for fair skin.

As someone who falls on the very pale end of the skin color spectrum, I frequently struggle to find a shade that doesn't leave my never-tan skin with an orange, oompa-loompa-esque tint. I refuse to look like a bad fake tan victim (and never do, thanks to my favorite self-tanners on the market), and I won't let a too-warm bronzer ruin that for me.

I'm fortunate to have dozens of bronzer formulas at my disposal, so I set off on a testing mission. Over the past few years, I've swatched and blended over 50 different bronzers from brands like Dior, Chanel, and Physician's Formula. Here, you'll find my definitive guide to bronzers for fair skin—an assortment of creams, liquids, and powders that will give even the lightest skin tones a subtle glow and ample cheekbone definition without the chalky, ruddy oxidation.

Best Bronzers for Fair Skin

Danielle Cohen is using the Dior Natural Bronzer with curly long brown hair and a turtleneck sweater, tank top against a window.

Danielle Cohen before and after testing the Forever Nude Jumbo Bronzer.

(Image credit: Future)

Danielle Cohen before and after using the Makeup by Mario SoftSculpt Transforming Skin Enhancer with glasses and a white t-shirt against a purple background.

Danielle Cohen before and after using the Makeup by Mario SoftSculpt Transforming Skin Enhancer.

(Image credit: Future)

Danielle Cohen before and after using the Chanel Bronzing Cream with damp, curly hair, green shade of polish on her nails, and a white t-shirt.

Danielle Cohen before and after using the Chanel Bronzing Cream

(Image credit: Future)

Danielle Cohen before and after applying the Benefit Hoola Bronzer with brown curly hair, and a black and white striped sweater, against a purple wall.

Danielle Cohen before and after applying the Benefit Hoola Bronzer.

(Image credit: Future)

How to Find The Best Bronzer Shade for Fair Skin

Pale skin tones should always look to the lightest available shades for their choice of bronzer. “Generally speaking, your bronzer color should be one to two shades darker than your surface tone (or skin tone),” makeup artist Priscilla Ono explains. You'll also want to consider your undertones. Brands typically group their shade ranges and undertones together, so finding one that works is easy.

If you’re not sure of your undertone, Ono recommends looking at the veins in your arm. "If they are blueish, you have a cool undertone; if they are greener, you’re warmer; and if you can’t really determine which shade you are, you’re more likely a neutral undertone,” she adds.

What Bronzer Formula Should I Use?

Powder, cream, and liquid formulas are at your disposal with fair skin, so it really depends on the finish you're looking for. "Liquid bronzers can be mixed into foundation for a subtle amp up on warmth and will dry down, while cream bronzers can stay looking dewy and blend into skin seamlessly for an effortless look," explains celebrity makeup artist Judi Gabbay Braha. On the other hand, powder bronzers are available in luminous and matte formulas, which can be great for oily skin types.

How to Apply Bronzer to Fair Skin

With fair skin, less is always more. "Apply bronzer where the sun would naturally hit—the forehead, tip of the nose, chin, and cheekbones," says Braha. If you're using a brush, make sure to tap off excess product. Place the product on the back of your hand first if you're using a cream. Building bronzer in light layers is key to looking glowy and tan, as opposed to overly orange.

How We Tested

Our testing process merged long-time editor favorites with new discoveries. We asked the Marie Claire team to share their favorite bronzers for fair skin, and tapped professional makeup artists to learn about their top picks. From there, we used reviews and online sentiment to select our top contenders.

We evaluated each on ease of use, durability, pigment payoff, shade range, and lasting power. We also considered packaging and versatility. Our resulting pool comprised the above top picks on the market.

Why Trust Marie Claire?

For more than 30 years, Marie Claire has been an internationally recognized destination for news, fashion, and beauty trends, investigative packages, and more. When it comes to the products Marie Claire recommends, we take your faith in us seriously. Every product that we feature comes personally recommended by a Marie Claire writer or editor, or by an expert we’ve spoken to firsthand.

Meet The Experts

.
Judi Gabbay Braha

Judi Gabbay Braha is a celebrity makeup artist based in New York. Her work has been featured in Seventeen Magazine, Vogue Italia, Marie Claire, Nylon and more. She has learned tricks of the Hollywood trade from top artists such as Mario Dedivanovic, Scott Barnes, Samuel Rauda and Patrick Ta. And, she's worked with networks such as Bravo, TLC, ABC and more.

Priscilla Ono
Priscilla Ono

Priscilla’s passion for beauty began in the ‘90s, while watching music videos on MTV. She has since translated her obsession for artistic expression into a 13-year career as a celebrity makeup artist and instructor, leading sold-out master classes and creating looks that have graced international magazine covers, campaigns, and red carpets.

TOPICS
Danielle Cohen
Contributing Beauty Writer

Danielle Cohen is a freelance beauty journalist with more than five years of industry experience and a lifetime of beauty obsession to boot. Her writing has appeared in AllureElleGlamourInStyleCosmopolitanAir Mail LookWell + GoodCR Fashion Book, Refinery29, and Byrdie, among others. When she’s not doling out SPF recommendations, you can find her sifting through celebrity blind items, working on the daily crossword, or walking her French bulldog, Rollo. Keep up with her on Instagram @daniellemcohen. 

With contributions from