Princess Beatrice and Princess Eugenie Face "Difficult Dilemma" Surrounding Princess Kate's Festive Invitation

Commentator Neil Sean says the "Royal Family wants to be seen as united amid what has been a very difficult year."

Princess Beatrice wearing a plaid coat and Princess Eugenie wearing a brown wrap coat in front of a flocked Christmas tree
(Image credit: Getty Images)

Princess Kate's annual Christmas carol service is just around the corner on December 5, and amid the festive cheer at Westminster Abbey, there's also the question of whether certain members of the Royal Family will attend. Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor has never gone to the concert—and is understood to have never received an invitation, in any case—but his daughters, Princess Beatrice and Princess Eugenie, are regular fixtures at the Together at Christmas event.

This year, the York sisters' attendance is unclear amid dad Andrew's title-stripping scandal and eviction from Royal Lodge. Buckingham Palace announced that The King had removed the former Duke of York's titles and honors, including his prince title, on October 30. However, Beatrice and Eugenie are still princesses, and their royal status has remained intact.

Whether they want to face the public and U.K. media at the carol concert is another story. British broadcaster Neil Sean told Fox News Digital that the sisters "received personal invitations" from Princess Kate's office for this year's concert, but the situation "puts the sisters in a very difficult dilemma."

Princess Beatrice, Princess Charlotte, Princess Kate, Edo Mapelli Mozzi, Princess Eugenie, Prince Louis holding candles in Westminster Abbey

Princess Charlotte (center) is seen standing between Princess Beatrice and her husband, Edoardo Mapelli Mozzi, at the 2023 Together at Christmas concert.

(Image credit: Getty Images)

"If they don’t attend, it looks like they’re snubbing a prestigious invite," Sean said. "If they do attend, they know there could be a media circus with them at the center of attention."

In terms of the guest list, Sean added, "This is Catherine’s project, and she has the final say—very similar to the way Prince William operates Earthshot. Above all, yes, the Royal Family wants to be seen as united amid what has been a very difficult year."

While Beatrice and Eugenie have generally kept a low profile over the past month, Princess Eugenie did attend a mentoring event for The King's Foundation in mid-November. Meanwhile, Princess Beatrice took on several engagements related to Borne, the premature birth charity where she serves as patron.

Edo Mapelli Mozzi, Princess Beatrice, Princess Eugenie and Jack Brooksbank wearing coats in front of a flocked Christmas tree

Edoardo Mapelli Mozzi (front left) and wife Princess Beatrice joined Princess Eugenie and her husband, Jack Brooksbank, at the 2022 Together at Christmas concert.

(Image credit: Getty Images)

According to Vanity Fair, King Charles is also considering giving his nieces more royal rules in the future, but is currently "testing the water" with public opinion.

As for the carol concert, held at Westminster Abbey, this year's theme will celebrate love in all its forms, with Kensington Palace noting, "In a world that can often feel fragmented and disconnected, love is the force that reconnects us all—spanning generations, communities, cultures, and faiths."

Kristin Contino
Senior Royal and Celebrity Editor

Kristin Contino is Marie Claire's Senior Royal and Celebrity editor. She's been covering royalty since 2018—including major moments such as the Platinum Jubilee, Queen Elizabeth II’s death and King Charles III's coronation—and places a particular focus on the British Royal Family's style and what it means.

Prior to working at Marie Claire, she wrote about celebrity and royal fashion at Page Six Style and covered royalty from around the world as chief reporter at Royal Central. Kristin has provided expert commentary for outlets including the BBC, Sky News, US Weekly, the Today Show and many others.

Kristin is also the published author of two novels, “The Legacy of Us” and “A House Full of Windsor.” She's passionate about travel, history, horses, and learning everything she can about her favorite city in the world, London.