Everything 'The Crown' Season 3 Got Wrong

Like: Margaret's U.S. tour went so badly, she was "banned" from returning.

3
(Image credit: Des Willie / Netflix)

Spoilers for season 3 ahead. The Crown is inspired by real-life events, (opens in new tab) but the show is, at its heart, a fictional narrative. Its cast and producers have always noted (opens in new tab) that creative liberties must be taken to fill in the blanks in what we don't know about the monarchy. That said, the show works hard to obtain historical accuracy in the costuming and imitation of real-life figures, down to mimicking royals' outfits and mannerisms (opens in new tab). So it's easy to forget that what's depicted on the show often doesn't reflect what really happened. That's part of the fun of The Crown—if you're anything like me, you're rapid-fire Googling the whole way through—but it's tough to parse where historical reality stops and historical fiction begins.

The third season in particular includes a few events that bypass historical accuracy in favor of bringing the drama. It's worth noting here that because The Crown comes closer to the present day, there are more records about what occurred—it's easier to fact-check, in other words, than previous seasons. So let's go ahead and do that, shall we?

Wrong: The Queen does occasionally cry in public.

In one of the best episodes of the entire series, "Aberfan," a devastating mining accident (opens in new tab) that robs a community of almost all of its children sparks national grief and anger. Unlike politicians, the media, and other royals, the Queen initially does not visit the Welsh mining village to meet with grieving families (this part is true), and she eventually reveals that she struggles to cry and feels unable to give the public any show of grief.

This is not true—the Queen has definitely cried (opens in new tab) at public events before—and Harold Wilson's then-secretary has gone on the record to say that, contrary to what the show depicts, the Queen was not faking her tears at Aberfan. (opens in new tab)

MORE ON 'THE CROWN'

Aberfan Disaster

(Image credit: I C Rapoport)

What is true is that there's a stigma about women crying in public, particularly powerful women. It remains relevant that Elizabeth was raised to have a stiff upper lip, and then criticized for it in the national press.

Wrong: Margaret's trip to the U.S. was not a roaring success.

It was so much not a roaring success, in fact, that Margaret was "banned (opens in new tab)" from returning to the U.S. in the '70s (lol). In the show, Margaret helps secure a bailout from the U.S. from President Lyndon B. Johnson—this isn't true; bailout talks continued for years after her visit—and she arouses so much public love that her megafans started calling themselves "Margaretologists (opens in new tab)" (also not really true; the term had been around before that).

MORE ON 'THE CROWN'

President Johnson Dances With Princess Margaret

(Image credit: Mark Kauffman)

In reality, the tour was outrageously expensive, Margaret offended a bunch of people, and her rendezvous with Johnson was...unremarkable (opens in new tab). The show uses the event as an opportunity for Margaret to once more ask for more royal duties (opens in new tab) and once more be rejected, but it's unclear whether that happened either.

Wrong: A lot of the Princess Alice stuff.

Oof, this one has a ton of inaccuracies (opens in new tab). So, yes, Princess Alice did come to live in Buckingham Palace because there was so much unrest in Greece (she was also a member of the Greek royal family), and she did reconcile with her estranged son Philip before she died two years later.

However. Alice was not interviewed and written about in glowing terms by Guardian's John Armstrong (fun fact: There is no John Armstrong (opens in new tab)), and she did not "save" the family from embarrassment because of an ill-timed and wrong-footed documentary (which did exist) (opens in new tab) that went behind the scenes in Buckingham Palace. The documentary was reviewed well, and it seems Alice didn't get interviewed by anyone.

MORE ON 'THE CROWN'

Princess Alice

(Image credit: Hulton Archive)

With all that said, "Bubbikins" is another sweet and deeply sentimental episode, and well worth the watch—despite the creative leaps. 

Wrong: Prince Philip didn't respond negatively to the moon landing.

The astronauts that participated in the Apollo 11 mission (Buzz Aldrin, Michael Collins, and Neil Armstrong) did visit the palace, but there's no evidence (opens in new tab) to suggest that Philip either met with them alone or that it made him feel lost about his purpose in the world.

MORE ON 'THE CROWN'

Philip did rekindle his faith (opens in new tab) later in life, which is one part of the episode, but it's not clear if the mid-life crisis depicted on the show—if it ever existed—precipitated the renewed focus in his life.

Wrong: The Queen didn't read Charles' private letters.

When Elizabeth goes to visit her exiled uncle Edward VIII and his wife Wallis Simpson just before his death—which did happen (opens in new tab), by the way—they talk about Charles.

MORE ON 'THE CROWN'

Elizabeth And Charles

(Image credit: Hulton Archive)

Edward and Charles enjoy a close relationship (semi-true) that includes letter-writing (opens in new tab) about Charles' personal life (not true). Edward gives the letters to Elizabeth and encourages her to understand her son better, although it has the opposite effect. (More on that below.) But although we don't know exactly what was said between Elizabeth and Edward on his deathbed, what seems clear is that there were no letters to give her from Charles.

Wrong: the Royal Family didn't "conspire" to take Charles away from Camilla.

There's always been a ton of speculation around exactly what happened in the initial relationship between Camilla Shand (Camilla Parker Bowles) and Charles. We know she was deemed "unsuitable (opens in new tab)" and too common, and that Charles was encouraged to date around before he settled down. But The Crown goes so far as to suggest that Mountbatten and the Queen Mother 1) send Charles away on an overseas assignment, 2) sit down with Andrew Parker Bowles and Camilla's families, and 3) "orchestrate (opens in new tab)" a marriage between Camilla and Andrew.

MORE ON 'THE CROWN'

This is, according to historians, not true. The Queen Mother never liked Mountbatten, and Camilla was deeply in love with Andrew. However, the timing of some of the events is interesting...although, again, there's no evidence to suggest Mountbatten deliberately chose Charles' assignment to the Caribbean (opens in new tab) for nefarious purposes. 

Wrong: The timing of Margaret's affairs.

Margaret started a relationship with Roddy Llewellyn, a much younger man, towards the end of her doomed marriage to Antony Armstrong-Jones (a.k.a. Lord Tony Snowdon). When pictures of the two (opens in new tab) were taken while they were on vacation in Mustique, it sets Margaret and Snowdon on the path towards the end of their marriage.

MORE ON 'THE CROWN'

Princess Margaret and Roddy Llwellyn

(Image credit: Hulton Deutsch)

In the wake of the scandal, her husband's declaration that he'd divorce her, and Roddy leaving her all at the same time, Margaret (trigger warning: self harm at the next link) takes an overdose of pills (opens in new tab) but recovers. The show intimates something more serious, but the truth is a little different; Margaret later said, "I was so exhausted because of everything that all I wanted to do was sleep...and I did, right through to the following afternoon." In reality, she and Roddy were involved with each other even after the divorce, and they remained friends until the end of her life.

For more stories like this, including celebrity news, beauty and fashion advice, savvy political commentary, and fascinating features, sign up for the Marie Claire newsletter.

subscribe here (opens in new tab)

RELATED STORY

the crown season 4

(Image credit: Des Willie)
Katherine J. Igoe
Katherine J. Igoe

Katherine’s a Boston-based contributor at Marie Claire who covers fashion, culture, and lifestyle—from “Clueless” to Everlane to news about Lizzo. She’s been a freelancer for 11 years and has had roles with Cosmopolitan and Bustle, with bylines in Parents, Seventeen, and elsewhere. It’s “I go to dinner,” not “Her huge ego,” but she responds to both.