Nicole Kidman
"I just remember I liked you," Kidman told Fallon, who has appeared twice now on the celeb crush list, in a hilariously open dialogue during her appearance on his show in 2015, recounting the story of their meeting and potential for a date years ago. "So Rick, our mutual friend, says 'Oh, you know, Jimmy wants to meet you and you can go over to his apartment'...and I'm single, and I'm like 'Yeah, cool,'" she explained.
"And after about an hour and a half, I was like 'he has *no* interest. This is so embarrassing,'" Kidman laughed. It was clear that Fallon, busy living his "video games and sneakers," lifestyle, as he claims, was too clueless at the time to realize the opportunity he was passing up.