Separated and questioned the next morning, two singles gave us all the details of their one-night stand
James, 25, investment banker: My friend Darrin called, and we decided to go to the 40/40 club.
Lisa, 26, teacher: Wanting to party like I did in grad school, I drank four Red Bull and vodkas with my friend Rachel.
James: Lisa walked into the club, and I noticed her immediately. She looked at me with those "come get me" eyes.
Lisa: When we got to the club, we went straight to the bar.
James: I went to the restroom and walked right past Lisa. I said hi to her, and we started dancing.
Lisa: I don't really remember meeting James, but I danced a lot with Rachel and a few other dudes.
James: Lisa started kissing me.
Lisa: I started getting really hungry.
James: We left to go eat.
Lisa: This is when I first really noticed James. I thought he was cute.
James: After the restaurant, we went to my place. Lisa lay down, and I asked her if she was sleepy. She said, "No, I'm waiting for you."
Lisa: We went to James's room, and he started taking his clothes off. He had an awesome body.
James: We were making out, and then she went down on me -- it was only about a minute, but it was great.
Lisa: I was feeling really lazy because I was drunk. I went down on him, but I wasn't really into it.
James: I almost went down on her, but I got the vibe she didn't want me to.
Lisa: He was kissing my back and I wanted him to go down on me, but then he tried to, um...lick my no-touch zone. I freaked out and flipped over.
James: I got a condom, and we started having sex doggie-style, my favorite.
Lisa: He has a mirror right above his headboard. He kept staring at it -- he was really obsessed with himself.
James: I usually dominate in the bedroom, but Lisa started riding me and was really good at it.
Lisa: I did my froggie trick -- where I'm on top and I place my feet on either side of him and bounce up and down.
James: We both climaxed.
Lisa: He came. I didn't.
James: When we woke up and started talking, I realized that she hadn't said my name in a while.
Lisa: He kissed me and then said, "Do you know my name?" I didn't.
James: She squirmed for a few minutes and said, "Will."
Lisa: I tried to stall, hoping my memory would kick in.
James: I told her I was going to punish her for not knowing.
Lisa: He started spanking me, and I knew he wanted to have sex again.
James: We had sex, and it was awesome. She kept screaming my name to make up for not knowing it.
Lisa: Sex wasn't great; he kept saying, "What's my name?!"
James: I'd like to see her again.
Lisa: I'm not going to call him. He's kind of full of himself.
More from Marie Claire: